Best 3D TVs

3D televisions certainly have big shoes to fill. Watching a 3D film at the cinema is loads of fun -- the glasses work well, the screen is huge and there's nothing to distract you from all that multi-dimensional action. Sadly, you can forget about enjoying a similar experience at home anytime soon.

The impressive 3D effect of films at the cinema comes courtesy of shockingly expensive digital projectors that beam two slightly different images onto the screen. The cheap polarised glasses you wear simply filter the correct image into each eye.
 
At home, however, the 3D smarts are housed in special 'active shutter' glasses that contain their own miniature LCD screens. When the TV shows an image destined for your left eye, the right lens of the glasses goes black, and vice versa. If the images alternate quickly enough -- and the TV is perfectly synchronised -- your brain will merge the two into a single 3D image. Unfortunately, it's still early days for this technology and the quality of 3D visuals varies.
 
When buying a 3D TV, the most important thing is to test it for yourself at different screen sizes. Imagine sitting down and watching a 90-minute film or football match. Can you see any distracting ghosting (this can happen if the glasses and TV aren't properly synched)? Does the image suffer if you stand up or watch it from the side? More importantly, are the glasses well-fitted and comfortable to wear? If you wear specs or contact lenses, try the 3D glasses with and without them.

Although all active-shutter systems work in a similar way, rival brands' offerings may not be compatible with one another, so check if friends and family have already bought 3D gear. Remember that extra pairs of glasses cost around £100 each. Ask yourself: do they feel sturdy enough to endure daily use?

All of the big-brand 3D tellies will work with any 3D Blu-ray player or 3D games console (currently only the PlayStation 3). If you're planning on using the TV for 3D gaming, try a few sessions of Mafia II beforehand. People tend to sit closer to the TV when gaming and this may affect the screen size you go for.

There are other choices to make, too. Plasma TVs often look better than LCD sets in the showroom because they're great at delivering smooth, flicker-free video (particularly useful with 3D content). But, when installed in a sunny room with windows, plasma screens can look slightly faded and washed-out.

When you buy a 3D TV today, you're essentially buying a top-notch, high-definition 2D television that happens to offer 3D as well. These models should have superb video playback, smooth (240Hz) motion control, loads of connections and possibly Internet access, with widgets and Wi-Fi connectivity. Even if 3D television winds up being a mere novelty, you'll still have a great set to last you until the next craze. Smell-o-vision anyone?

Here's the CNET UK line-up of the best 3D sets on the market today.

Editors:

3.5 stars out of 5

Users:

5 stars out of 5

Sony Bravia HX903 (KDL-46HX903)

The Sony Bravia KDL-46HX903 is a good, but not great, TV. It's overpriced for what it is, and we'd pick Panasonic or Samsung's 3D models over this one every time Read more

£2,500

Reviewed on 23 July 2010

Editors:

5.0 stars out of 5

Users:

4.85 stars out of 5

Panasonic Viera VT20 (TX-P46VT20)

Panasonic still delivers the best 3D in town. Perhaps more importantly, the Viera TX-P46VT20 is a knockout 2D set. It's extremely well-equipped, with picture quality that movie fans will love. Read more

£1,900

Reviewed on 22 September 2010

Editors:

4.5 stars out of 5

Users:

4.75 stars out of 5

Samsung C8000 (UE46C8000)

Excellent 2D and 3D performance along with a stylish design make the 46-inch Samsung UE46C8000 an easy TV to recommend. Read more

£1,400

Reviewed on 29 September 2010

Editors:

4.5 stars out of 5

Users:

0 out of 5

Not yet rated

Philips 9000 (32PFL9705/12)

The 32-inch Philips 32PFL9705/12 is expensive and can be a little fiddly to use, but it delivers stunning picture quality and impressively beefy sound. Read more

£1,300

Reviewed on 30 September 2010

Comments 11

Add your comment

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 18 September, 2010 10:38

I cannot remember being this excited about new tech as I am with 3D tvs, it is a shame the glasses are expensive but, I think they look really good, I do not think people would watch 3D all the time anyway. I have always loved 3D and hope this technology really is a success and hope that other supporters come out of the woodwork, ( I need 3D to last as I do not stand the chance, if ever, of affording one)lol

Anonymous's avatar

Anonymous 1 January, 2011 20:01

Hi,
I have a panasonic viera 42inch 3d tv and although im waiting for most the films to come in the post i LOVE IT. Why people still criticise the technology is beyond me embrace this it is here to stay.... i hope

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 30 April, 2011 07:53

I think the consumers are waiting for glass-less 3D t.v,s before making an expensive purchase that,s why they retailers are pratically giving t.v,s away i sore yesterday a lg 42" 1080p LED with 24p movie feature for £299 ! 3D t.v with glasses was just an inter-rim idea for t.v manufactors which hasn,t worked

Anonymous's avatar

Anonymous 24 May, 2011 09:31

can anyone give the solution about cinema 3d TV by which should i enjoy a lot but i am planning to buy a LG cinema 3d tv because i read out about its features & LG is using FPR technology which provide brighter and clearer image.

sumit22's avatar

sumit22 24 May, 2011 10:24

this is a good quote given in this article that when you should go the market to buy a 3d tv first you test 3d tv by yourself from different-2 angles like screen sizes, image quality, sound and other features etc.

Anonymous's avatar

Anonymous 31 May, 2011 10:34

I 've also read about FPR 3d tv glasses. they are literally awesome in features; still i don't have any experience to share.

geoffh's avatar

geoffh 31 May, 2011 22:51

try looking at a samsung ued7000,that will convince you that this IS the technology.

Anonymous's avatar

Anonymous 21 June, 2011 10:32

I am afraid, i will have nothing to share since in this article there is no LG brand. In all the panel technology the best panel is the In plane Switching (IPS) Panel and for the 3D TV is the FPR technology. Therefore it is up to youto choice the best or worst.

Anonymous's avatar

Anonymous 23 June, 2011 07:18

Yes, the tech makes all the difference, in LG the best thing is the IPS panel and the FPR tech which really make them to have an upper hand in the market as it is superior to other brand.

Anonymous's avatar

Anonymous 4 July, 2011 18:09

I had always doubted the LG TV's quality of picture but the new 3D Cinema Passive TV's are now far better than any other brand. I have the LG 47 550 LED Series and the 2D picture is brilliant as is the 3D picture plus the fact that the Cinema Passive glasses are far less stressful to the eyes than the active shutter systems used by every other brand so far and cost next to nothing (7 Came free with the set),

I also have a Panasonic 42" GT 20 3D Plasma TV and the 2D picture is excellent but the 3D is literally an eye sore. The active shutter system is not only expensive (2 Free glasses with purchase) but with the flickering in anything but a dark room is positively painful. Maybe just me but the LG Passive wins hands down on all fronts

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 3 January, 2012 18:34

Hi Just bought a Techneka 42" 3d tv, does anyone have any comments on them,( surely I'm not the only one to buy one???? ) the back doesn't look strong enough for wall mounting although Tesco and the company suplying the bracket say that's not a problem, not had the courage to fix to wall yet. tv works well good picture especially on 3d. so comments please.

Post your comment

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Your email will not be displayed with your comment

Copy the letters and numbers to prove that you're human. You won't have to do this if you log in or register

Your comment must comply with the Terms of Use

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2012 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.