42-inch flat-screen TVs: LCD vs Plasma

Since TV screens started to slim down, the demand for larger screen sizes has grown. Space-saving designs mean that even smaller rooms can accommodate a large screen without being overwhelmed. With manufacturers producing TVs in ever-increasing sizes and prices becoming more affordable, there's never been a better time to take a look at the bigger picture.

Anything above 42 inches was once reserved for plasma, but improved technology has seen LCDs invade the large-screen domain. Each technology has its strengths and weaknesses -- plasma offers better contrast, more cohesive movement and more natural colours, while LCDs produce brighter images that bring out more detail and have more engaging colours. It all comes down to personal choice, but we've collected four 42-inch models from competing technologies to help grease your decision-making gears.

Toshiba's 42WLT66 is an affordable LCD model that features 'Full HD' compatibility, integrated Freeview and dual HDMI connectivity. If you're into high definition then the full 1,920x1,080-pixel resolution means you can play 1080i signals in their entirety without any downscaling. Two HDMI inputs allow you to connect two high-definition sources simultaneously. Picture performance is superb with high definition but standard definition isn't as impressive.

If you can afford to spend more, then Philips' 42PF8931D is the class-leading LCD in this size. Not only do you get a well-balanced specification featuring advanced processing, but the jaw-dropping design using Ambilight Surround technology is guaranteed to turn heads. Even with a normal HD Ready 1,366x768-pixel resolution, we've never seen high-definition images so clean, smooth and detailed -- which makes the expensive price tag easier to ignore.

Samsung's PS42Q7 offers excellent value for money with fewer compromises than you would expect from a plasma priced around £1,000. Not many budget models offer such a striking design integrated with high-end features, such as high-definition compatibility and a digital tuner. Connectivity is comparatively restricted by single input options and performance doesn't scale class-leading heights, but it's still an absolute steal.

Panasonic's slightly more expensive TH42PX60 is one of the finest plasma models to come from the market-leading Viera range. It's a screen that has it all, including an attractive design, state-of-the-art specification with complete connectivity and user-friendly functionality. Superb black levels offer images with outstanding contrast and detail, while perfectly balanced colours and natural movement provide more realism than LCDs can muster.

Editors:

3.5 stars out of 5

Users:

3.1 stars out of 5

Toshiba 42WLT66

Despite its rather poor standard-definition showing, this is a fantastic screen for the price -- at least for those who have hi-def video sources or are planning on getting some soon. It's compact, easy to set up and live with and is the cheapest 'full 1080' 42-inch LCD around Read more

£1,465

Reviewed on 21 July 2006

Editors:

4.5 stars out of 5

Users:

4 stars out of 5

Philips 42PF9831D

Philips' new ClearLCD technology takes big-screen LCD picture performance to a new level, especially with high definition. That this picture prowess is joined by a stunning design and a seemingly endless feature count is just the icing on a particularly sweet cake Read more

£550

Reviewed on 16 June 2006

Editors:

3.5 stars out of 5

Users:

4.25 stars out of 5

Samsung PS42Q7HD

Samsung's 42Q7HD is stunningly designed and impressively equipped with a future-proof specification. There are a few sound and picture flaws but at this price they're easy to ignore Read more

£370

Reviewed on 27 June 2006

Editors:

4.0 stars out of 5

Users:

4.65 stars out of 5

Panasonic Viera TH42PX60

The Viera range has kept on improving over the past couple of years, and this is the high point so far. An excellent marriage of design and performance, this plasma is one of the very best -- if not one of the cheapest -- money can buy Read more

£1,900

Reviewed on 7 April 2006

Post your comment

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Will not be displayed with your comment

Copy the letters and numbers to prove that you're human. You won't have to do this if you log in or register

Your comment must comply with the Terms of Use

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2012 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.