Rear-projection televisions
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Guy Cocker
Last updated: 08 Mar 2006
All the fuss over flat-screen TV has taken the limelight away from the humble rear-projection television. Rear-pro's physical similarity to the CRT TVs of old mean it's less attractive than its plasma and LCD contemporaries, but rear-pro is still the best way of getting a huge screen at an affordable price. The high contrast and cinematic picture quality mean that these TVs are perfect for movie lovers, and all the sets below are also HD Ready.
We've been seriously impressed with Sagem's recent rear-projection TVs, and the HD-D45H is the best one yet. The company is one of the few seriously committed to projection technology, and while the new HD4 DLP chipset is slightly weaker than the HD2+ for picture performance, it's still miles ahead of most flat screens. The television is stylish and well featured, with a Freeview tuner and two HDMI inputs. And given the size of the screen, it's amazingly good value.
Sony's catchily named KDF-E50A12U is light on features but its slimmed-down chassis makes it attractive to the style-conscious buyer. The picture quality is excellent and the connectivity will fulfil all your high-definition requirements, while there's an integrated Freeview tuner with support for the seven-day electronic programme guide. High-definition pictures are unbeatable, and the 3LCD chipset may not be popular, but it still produces good standard-definition results.
Samsung's SP-50L7HX has been one of the company's flagship TVs for some time, and its unique design has won it more awards than any other rear-projection TV. It certainly looks amazing, and it will also please the gadget fans thanks to its HD Ready badge. Samsung's DNIe image-processing system produces great results from standard-definition sources, although the lack of digital tuner means that you'll have to buy your own. The viewing angle is slightly more limited than the other TVs in this roundup, but if you want to make a style statement, there's nothing that matches this Samsung.
Toshiba's 52WM48P is ageing now, but it still offers high-definition compatibility, excellent connectivity and a really bright picture. It's more mundanely designed than Samsung's effort, and the picture quality is slightly grainy, but it looks fantastic when you run movies through its component video inputs. It's also a great price for its 52-inch screen size -- only the lack of Freeview tuner and occasional rainbow effects could be rectified with an updated model.
Compare Products
![]() Sagem HD-D45H |
![]() Sony KDF-E50A12U |
![]() Toshiba 52WM48P |
![]() Samsung SP-50L7HX |
|
| Review date | 2 Mar 06 | 17 Jan 06 | 15 May 05 | 15 May 05 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £1,300 | £1,220 | £1,900 | £2,500 |
| Review summary | Sagem's excellent line in rear-projection TVs gets better, thanks to an integrated Freeview tuner and four HD video inputs. Also new to the roster is a new DLP chipset, which has mixed results but doesn't prevent excellent standard- and high-definition picture quality. The wealth of features and modern styling are one thing, but the superb value that the TV offers makes it top of our big-screen budget choices Read full review |
Rear-projection performance has greatly improved and screens are no longer as cumbersome as they once were. Sony's KDF-E50A12U may not be as slim as a flat screen, but the price and specification make it an attractive option -- even if it is light on features Read full review |
Toshiba's 52WM48P is a good value buy -- after all, you're getting 52 inches of screen for under £2,000. The design is modern and stylish, the connectivity is excellent and it's fully equipped for high-definition pictures. However, it's facing particularly stylish competition from Samsung in the rear-projection market and the Toshiba just loses out in comparison Read full review |
The SP-50L7HX is like no other TV around, rear-pro or otherwise. Projection TVs tend to split people into either the plaudit or critic camps, so if you're not already a fan, this is unlikely to convert you. However, Samsung preaches to the converted with a deeply impressive picture performance, a multitude of sources and full high-definition compatibility Read full review |
| User rating | ||||
| Product Type | Rear Projection | Rear Projection | n/a | n/a |
| Diagonal size | 45 in. | 50 in. | 52 in. | 50 in. |
| Image aspect ratio | 16:9 | 16:9 | 16:9 | 16:9 |
| Resolution | 1280 x 720 pixels | 1280 x 720 pixels | 1280 x 720 pixels | 1280 x 768 pixels |
| Image contrast ratio | 3000:1 | n/a | 1000:1 | n/a |
| Screen brightness | 700 cd/m2 | n/a | 600 cd/m2 | 1000 cd/m2 |
| Speakers included | 2.1 | 2 | 2 | 4 |
| Dual TV Tuner | No | Yes | n/a | No |
| Sky High Definition compatible | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Full specification | Full specification | Full specification | Full specification |
Want to compare other products?
You can choose up to four products to compare on the Compare Products page






