Apple iPod touch review

In this review

Minus a few features, the Safari Web browser found on the iPod touch is more or less the same great browser found on the iPhone. For instance, without the iPhone's email application or phone capabilities, email addresses and phone numbers found on Web pages will no longer launch email or dialling options.

Web-based email, such as Gmail or Yahoo mail, work fine in Safari, but without the ability to copy and paste text, manually entering in email addresses found on the Web can be frustrating. Just like Safari on the iPhone, Flash-based Web objects are still disabled, including embedded video players and music players.

We'd love to see embedded Flash support in the otherwise fabulous browser. Whether video content from sites like DailyMotion or Viddler or music from Web radio sites like Pandora or Slacker, embedded Flash media content is a big part of the Internet media experience.

Despite these few limitations, using Safari on a small mobile device like the iPod touch is still fun and useful. The intelligent touchscreen keyboard and multiple browser window management are a big plus.

Both the iPod touch and iPhone allow users to browse, preview, purchase and download music from the new iTunes Wi-Fi music store, which will open in the UK in time for the launch of the touch. The store is limited strictly to music downloads -- no movies, TV shows, podcasts or games -- at least, not yet. You'll have to hop onto an available Wi-Fi Internet connection to take advantage of the wireless music store but once connected, you can search for any artist, album or song in the iTunes catalogue, as well as browse by genre, top sellers, featured artists and new releases. Store purchases require you to enter your iTunes password as a security measure.

Once the download is complete, the song is immediately available to listen to and will transfer to your computer's iTunes music library the next time you sync the device. The feature seemed to work without any kinks when we tried it in the US. Even interrupted downloads picked up once a Wi-Fi connection is re-established.

Complaining about the iPod touch's lack of FM radio or voice-recording features feels like complaining about a Porsche's lack of cup holders. Still, there are some missing features on the iPod touch that we would have enjoyed. High-capacity SD memory card expansion is at the top of our list of most-wanted features for the touch. We could easily forgive any portable video player's limited built-in memory capacity if the option of SD memory card expansion was available (the Archos 405 or Creative Zen are perfect examples of video players that give us the option to expand).

Performance
Putting aside the touch's sleek design, futuristic interface and innovative feature set, the quality of its audio and video playback rank only slightly above average. The iPod touch reportedly uses the same audio chipset as the iPhone, but a different one to the iPod classic. The touch offers good audio quality, but not the stellar audio we were hoping for in an expensive product.

User reviews6

Add your review

VOXTER's avatar
2.5 stars out of 5

VOXTER 2 February 2009

Good: Overall product design, Functions, WiFi

Bad: No Bluetooth, Sound Quality, iTunes, Pricy

Comment: Well, I'd like to keep this review as short as possible thereby I'll jz get it going

I've been using several MP3-Players from Samsung, Cowon, iRiver or Sony and among these, Apple offers the most edge-cutting design and functionality. Basically there is nothing you can't actually change. Furthermore, WiFi-supports is pretty effective but that's about it.

The iPod does not support bluetooth, which is really a pity for users who value wirelss devices. Further iTunes is without questions, a good tool, but it still causes too many problems. And to get to the core of problems: Sound-Quality.

From my point of view, Apple were able to sell a lot of their devices due to its exclusive features, and not because of its quality as a MP3 Player. Of course, those are the features people ask for, but we have to keep in mind, isn't a MP3-Players main purpose to play music in the highest possible definition?
Apple iPod Touch fails to do so, by A. providing below-average sound quality and B. not supporting HQ audio codecs such as FLAC, AAC or OGG.
Thereby my final word is: The iPod Touch is a fine deal for those who are looking for an overall device, but who really do not care about the specific qualities such as audio quality et.al.. For people who are looking for an outstanding audio envoirment grab one of the Samsung or Sony Devices.

Let's just take the P3 from Samsung as an example:

Design: Apple
Functionality: "Even" (It comes out to WiFi vs. Bluetooth but I say BT bcz WiFi is useless without a hotspot)
Audio-Quality: Samsung (DNSE3.0)
Video-Quality: Samsung (HD
Supported Formats: Samsung (FLAC, OGG. AAC)

Score: 3:1 Samsung YP-P3

I don't want to get into each and every detail, but Sony and Cowon S9 are as good as the YP-P3. Anyhow thats it.

bom194's avatar
5 stars out of 5

bom194 6 December 2008

Good: style shape, applications (best to update to 2.0), wieght, games , everything about basicly

Bad: no speakers, no nike thing mabob, still dont buy the 2nd gen

Comment: this is better than the 2nd en ill tel you why it can jailbreak and you can custimize it to the max the wallpaper,slider,aplplications, ect
BEST IPOD EVER. IF YOU BUY ONE THING IN YOUR LIFE BUY THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!

Adam Talmondt's avatar
4.5 stars out of 5

Adam Talmondt 19 April 2008

Good: WI-FI and touchscreen

Bad: Fingerprints everywhere

Comment: Brilliant ipod, best one yet. WI-FI is truely amazing, easy interface, touchscreen is suprisingly responsive and easy to use. I feel that it would be hard to take everywhere as an ipod though because of the price and if it gets a major scratch on it I will not be too happy.

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should I buy it?

Front of iPod touch

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the Apple iPod touch

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2012 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.