This web site uses cookies to improve your experience. By viewing our content, you are accepting the use of cookies. To find out more and change your cookie settings, please view our cookie policy. Close

Apple iPod shuffle (3rd generation, 4GB) review

In this review

As far as charging goes, the shuffle comes with a 10cm (4-inch) USB adaptor that connects between the headphone output and your computer. The shuffle is rated at 10 hours of playback time -- 2 hours less than the previous generation, but still enough to get you through a week's worth of casual use. A full recharge should take about 3 hours.

It's also worth noting that the shuffle can be used on your computer in disk mode, allowing you to store and transfer files without interfering with the audio content on your iPod. As expected, you can't access the music files stored on the shuffle without going through iTunes (version 8.1 or later is a required download for the shuffle).

Performance
Compared with other sub-£60 MP3 players on the market (for example, the SanDisk Sansa Clip or Creative Zen Stone Plus), the shuffle's microscopic design isn't enough to make up for the limited features, relatively high price, diminished battery life, quirky navigation and a headphone remote system that reeks of planned obsolescence.


The headphone remote system will undoubtedly put some people off

MP3 players like the shuffle that are aimed at the gym and jogger crowd are particularly susceptible to issues of headphone fit, comfort, and wear and tear, and Apple's headphone remote needlessly complicates the process of replacing or upgrading the shuffle's earbuds. This is not to say that the headphone control is a bad feature, but also having controls on the actual device would help avoid navigation-related confusion and improve the product's usefulness in the long term.

The third-generation shuffle's audio quality is noticeably better than that of the previous generation, and sounds comparable to that of the fourth-generation iPod nano and second-generation iPod classic. The sound has a fuller range, with better bass response and less background hiss. Of course, the improvement in audio quality is hard to notice using the bundled earbuds, and standard headphones lack the remote control necessary for adjusting volume and skipping tracks. But, when the shuffle is connected to a standard pair of headphones and then powered on, it automatically starts playing music at the volume level it was last set to.

Third-party accessories such as replacement headphones, headphone adaptors and remote-equipped auxiliary cables will soon be available for the third-generation shuffle. If you expect to use the shuffle with an existing pair of headphones, a home stereo or a car stereo, you should add the cost of some of these accessories to the purchase price.

Conclusion
The third-generation shuffle has plenty going for it: the aluminium and steel construction is sturdy, the design is unobtrusive, there's a whopping 4GB of storage, and the VoiceOver technology allows you to control playback without taking your eyes away from what you're doing. But sacrifices have been made elsewhere to achieve the small size and minimalistic design, and we have a hard time giving the shuffle an unqualified thumbs-up.

Additional editing by Charles Kloet

  • Print

User reviews3

Add your review

Joshua Barker's avatar
4 stars out of 5

Joshua Barker 30 December 2012

Good: Small Size, Stylish

Bad: Headphones deteriorate

Comment: The Shuffle 3 is perfect for my favourite songs when on my bike, but I do prefer a screen for my entire library on my Nano. The shuffle has no playback controls and so ideally requires headphones with the control, but any headphones will play music at a reasonable volume if you plug them in and switch it to shuffle :)

I own it
superbunny's avatar
0.5 star out of 5

superbunny 26 August 2010

Good: Small and portable

Bad: Controls have migrated to earphone jack which easily get corroded and malfunction

Comment: I have religiously used a previous generation iPod shuffle until the battery wore out and I was required to replace it with the the new version I am reviewing here. At first I thought the migration of controls to the earphone jack was a super idea. However, the whole purpose of having a small, lightweight MP3 player without a lot of 'flash' is often to use it whilst doing sport -- like running, cycling, walking, etc.,... It turns out that shifting the controls onto the earphone jack is a rotten idea because they routinely malfunction when they come into contact with perspiration or sweat. Once the controls have become corroded, the player no longer functions and one must replace the earphone jack.

I own it
tursiops's avatar
2.5 stars out of 5

tursiops 16 March 2009

Good: Has 4Gb

Bad: Too small, learning curve for headphone

Comment: Sometimes making something smaller than it already is is not the best idea, and that is one of them.
I think this is a step backwards compared to the last shuffle, as it's not really easy to understand how to make it work, and inside the headphones there is this little chip that makes using other earphones impossible.
If you want a small and nice shuffle get the last version one.

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should I buy it?

Apple iPod shuffle front

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the Apple iPod shuffle (3rd generation, 4GB)

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2013 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.