Apple iPod (60GB, video) review

Our rating

4.0 stars out of 5

User rating

3 stars out of 5

See all 3 user reviews

What do you think?

Verdict

Buy the affordable, sleek and sexy fifth-generation Apple iPod for its audio virtues. Although video looks great, poor video battery life and a relatively small screen hamper its appeal to video enthusiasts

Good

  • Incredibly thin and intuitive design
  • Beautiful LCD
  • Supports photo and video playback
  • Seamless integration with iTunes, which boasts the world's biggest music catalogue and a new video store
  • Smooth video
  • Lots of extra features, such as a world clock, a stopwatch and PIM applications
  • A galaxy of accessories designed for the iPod
  • Great overall value

Bad

  • No extras included, such as a dock, AV cables or a power adaptor
  • Poor battery life for video
  • Slight delay when playing video
  • No guarantee that your non-iTunes Music Store video will play on an iPod, even after using converted third-party software
  • TV programmes not available on iTunes outside of the US yet

In this review

Pay close attention to the new Apple iPod when you first hold one in your hands. Most of you will notice a design that's thinner, lighter and sexier than its predecessor's, as well as a new screen that dwarfs the Click Wheel. A few of you will notice subtler differences, such as the absence of the smart headphone jack, a smaller Click Wheel and the iPod's superflat face. Experienced iPod users may complain that essentials such as a power adaptor and A/V cables aren't bundled with the device. But despite the fact that it is an audio player first and foremost, all of you will remember the fifth-generation iPod as the video iPod.

Those who follow gadgets know that Apple didn't invent portable digital video; companies such as Archos, Creative and iRiver have produced good if not stellar products that play back video -- and on larger screens with better battery life. But if Apple can do for video what it has done for audio -- that is, deliver a hardware/software ecosystem that offers a decent choice of content and makes it easy to get video on to the iPod -- then this device, like it or not, will be remembered as the one that started the portable digital video revolution.

The fifth-gen iPod, which is available in white or nano black and comes in 30GB and 60GB capacities for £219 and £299 respectively, is the best one we've used to date. Yet because it has added a major extra feature -- video playback -- to its solid, audiocentric foundation, there's room for improvement.

Design
In this era of seemingly unstoppable technological progress, the Apple iPod was due for an update both physically and featurewise. And the fifth-gen iPod is much more than a simple update. As with the nano before it, you have to see and touch the iPod in person to appreciate it. The 30GB body, which measures 62 by 104 by 11mm and weighs only 136g (add 3mm depth and 21g for the 60GB), is baby-soft to the touch, and while design elements such as the Click Wheel and a polished silver backside are familiar, this iPod has an added sexiness, thanks to the larger screen that dominates its upper half.


The fifth-gen iPod next to its predecessor


Apple somehow shrunk the width of the iPod body so drastically that the 30GB version is 31 per cent thinner than the 20GB iPod. The 60GB version measures only 14mm, meaning it too is thinner than the 20GB iPod. Personally, we think the older model, with its softer edges and added thickness, is a tad more hand-friendly. The Click Wheel, which utilises in-house technology (Apple has abandoned Synaptics tech, starting with the nano), is actually smaller -- by about 8mm in diameter -- than the fourth-gen iPod, which means you won't get as much scrolling action with each stroke of the thumb. The select button, which was slightly raised before, is now flat. The headphone jack has moved to the far right, and the smart jack, which was used by a host of accessories, such as the Apple in-line remote, has disappeared. The hold switch has moved from right to left, while the dock connector remains on the bottom, in the middle. Overall, the physical design is simpler and more refined, though slightly less ergonomic. Basically, you'll definitely get tired of holding the iPod in the 28th minute of viewing video.

User reviews3

Add your review

Jai Shailer's avatar
3.5 stars out of 5

Jai Shailer 8 June 2006

Good: The lovely design - sleek feel and look about it. If you are image-conscious like me, or care about the seamless music sychronisation this is a must.

Bad: The poor battery life when using video or the colour display in general.

Comment: The iTunes layout and flawless podcast and playlist simplicity for example; sends the iPod Video off with no hassle for gungeing it up wth all of your music. Innovative and stylish, this is a sure-fire from Apple.
But, on a negative 'dagger'; the battery life is called poor for a real reason.
It doesn't last long enough. :(
This should definitely be analysed and improved. A worrying prospect indeed...
Overall, if you want an ingenious and beautiful gadget that you can carry around with you with pride, purchase this!

Robin Lewis's avatar
2 stars out of 5

Robin Lewis 25 April 2006

Good: Storage capacity, video/photo picture quality, battery life for audio only

Bad: Not enough bass response, battery life too short for video, scratches ARE a problem with the 5th gen

Comment: Overall I would give this a 3 had it not been for video and photo quality, which brought it up to a 4. However, there is no real point in the video feature because of the drastic decrease in battery life. Unfortunately this does not have enough bass response and in my experience (keeping it in the supplied wallet) within the first few weeks of use hairline noticeable scratches appeared over the front of the iPod and screen, which is a problem (it wouldn't have been as bad if it wasn't for the fact that it makes video viewing more annoying). Overall, don't buy this for the iPod buzz or video capabilities, buy it for the great storage capacity and good photo quality and battery life for audio ONLY, which is sufficient.

Omogbolahan Ogunnaike's avatar
4 stars out of 5

Omogbolahan Ogunnaike 22 November 2005

Good: The simplicity of downloading music onto it.

Bad: Poor battery life

Comment: Apple can do a little bit better by finding a solution to the battery.

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should you buy it?

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the Apple iPod (60GB, video)

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2012 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.