Beyond ringtones: mobile phones that play music
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Mary Lojkine
Last updated: 24 Aug 2005
Now that it's almost impossible to buy a mobile phone without a built-in camera, manufacturers are looking for the next big thing. Given the popularity of the iPod and the astounding enthusiasm for ringtones, it's hardly surprising they've decided to bring music playback to your mobile.
There are a few things to watch out for when you're shopping for a music phone. First, how are you going to get your music on to the phone? If you're planning to download tracks from your service provider, it's worth thinking about a 3G phone. If you're going to copy it across from your computer, find out how the transfer works. Do you need a cable? Is it included with the phone? Can you use Bluetooth? Can you copy the files directly to a memory card? If transferring music is too much like hard work, you'll end up listening to the same songs over and over again.
Second, how much storage space do you get? It's unusual for a phone to have more than 100MB of built-in memory. You'll need some of that for contacts, photos, games and so on, so you'll be lucky to find space for more than 15-20 songs -- so you'll want to be able to add capacity using memory cards. Third, are you stuck with the supplied headphones, or can you use your own? Many phones use proprietary connectors rather than a standard 3.5mm jack.
Fourth, consider the battery life. If you just want to listen to music while you commute, for a couple of hours each day, and you can top up the battery at either end, you should be fine. Much more than that, though, and you run the risk of cutting yourself off. You'll have a hard time explaining that you missed an important call because you'd run down the battery listening to Coldplay.
Compare Products
![]() Motorola Rokr E1 |
![]() Sony Ericsson W800i |
![]() Orange SPV C550 |
![]() Samsung E720 |
|
| Review date | 20 Sep 05 | 17 Aug 05 | 3 Aug 05 | 21 Jun 05 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £210 | £370 | £150 | £280 |
| Review summary | The Rokr E1 is a generally average handset beefed up with good sound output and Apple's iTunes software. If you're an Apple fan and simply must have a phone that's compatible with iTunes, then the Rokr E1 is your only choice. But we'd suggest you take a long hard look at the new iPod nano, and consider buying that along with any other, better-equipped handset Read full review |
The W800i is a nicely featured handset, comfortable to use and with great battery life. It plays music reasonably well, and holds a lot of it thanks to the capacious bundled Memory Stick Pro Duo. But getting music onto the handset is difficult and the quality of sound output is poor. We'll wait for the next generation of music phone Read full review |
The SPV C550 is small, neat and ideal if you want easy synchronisation of diary and contacts with a PC. Despite the dedicated buttons, it doesn't offer enough internal memory to double as a music phone -- although the included 128Mb miniSD card does help Read full review |
The external MP3 and camera controls make this handset one for the multimedia fan, but beware the non-expandable memory. Hiding beneath what at first glance is a neat, tidy and fairly sober exterior lies a bright, clear internal screen and an overabundance of colours and sounds. It's bling bling rather than ring ring Read full review |
| User rating | ||||
| Form factor | Candy-bar | Candy-bar | Candy-bar | Clamshell |
| Weight | 107 g | 99 g | 107 g | 90 g |
| Talk time (mfr) | 560 min | 540 min | 240 min | 330 min |
| Standby time (mfr) | 230 hours | 400 hours | 144 hours | 200 hours |
| 3G | No | No | No | No |
| Camera resolution | 0.3 megapixels | 2 megapixels | 1.3 megapixels | 1 megapixels |
| Music playback | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| FM radio | No | Yes | No | No |
| Infrared | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Bluetooth | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Full specification | Full specification | Full specification | Full specification |
Want to compare other products?
You can choose up to four products to compare on the Compare Products page





