Ad: Get our free CNET Android app

Sony Ericsson Xperia X1 review

Our rating

3.5 stars out of 5

User rating

2.5 stars out of 5

See all 3 user reviews

What do you think?

Verdict

We really wanted to love the Sony Ericsson Xperia X1 as it boasts an attractive design and features the iPhone 3G would be jealous of, but it runs on Windows Mobile and as a consequence doesn't deliver a great user experience. If only the Xperia X1 ran on Android with all the Microsoft support of Windows Mobile and featured a more sensitive screen, then Sony Ericsson might have hit the jackpot

Typical price

£500

Good

  • Wi-Fi
  • HSDPA
  • Qwerty keypad
  • Large screen
  • 3.5mm headphone jack

Bad

  • Interface lags at times
  • Windows Mobile requires using a stylus for certain items

In this review

If you've followed Sony Ericsson's development roadmap like we have, then you'll know that the Xperia X1 represents a dramatic change in direction for a company that’s made many phones which look very similar to each other.

The Xperia X1 is different from anything Sony Ericsson has come up with before and hopefully signals a push towards a much more innovative future. Of course innovation can go wrong, but that's part of the risk. Read our review if you want to find out whether the gamble paid off.

You can get yourself a Sony Ericsson Xperia X1 for free on a monthly contract from Vodafone.

Design
Similar to the HTC Touch Pro, the Xperia X1 features a touchscreen on the front and hidden underneath a full slide-out Qwerty keypad. Our review model came in a serious but attractive black casing that's made up of metal and plastic sections. It feels solid and could most likely take a few tumbles. Most of the X1's surfaces aside from the screen are matte which means you don't get fingerprints all over it.


The Sony Ericsson Xperia X1 has a slide-out Qwerty keypad that's great for typing out long emails 

The Xperia's touchscreen is very sharp and large enough to enjoy viewing emails and videos, but it's noticeably smaller than the iPho ne 3G's, which may bother you depending on what you use it for.

We found the X1's screen fairly responsive but not as responsive as the iPhone's when using a finger. It's made less finger-friendly due to the Windows Mobile's interface that regularly requires using a stylus to tap on smaller sections of the menu or texting interface, for example.

If navigating the touchscreen using your finger or the X1's stylus winds you up, then you can always use the four-way navigation key underneath the screen. Bizarrely, the navigation key features an optical sensor in the middle, which also doubles up as an OK button.

The optical sensor allows you to scroll through the X1's menu by simply stroking it and while it is useful at times, we found it made navigation over-complicated. Every time you inadvertently brush the sensor it can cause something to move on the screen which can get a bit annoying at times. 

One of the X1's most exciting features is its slide-out Qwerty keypad that we were keen to test out. It slides out at a curved angle and boasts a backlight for use in the dark. There's no need for it to curve but several people remarked that it looks good. 

We'd like to report that the X1's keypad delighted us but we found the keys a little too flat and ill-defined. You do get used to using it, but it's certainly not perfect. A better keypad would feature keys that were more raised in the middle so that you can feel them better as you're typing. 

Something we did think was perfect about the X1's design is the built-in 3.5mm headphone jack, which lets you plug your standard headphones straight in -- a feature we want to see on more Sony Ericsson phones, in particular its Walkman range of phones. 

User reviews3

Add your review

asiakowa's avatar
1.5 stars out of 5

asiakowa 9 May 2012

Good: I see almost nothing. I would not expect a phone like that from sony branded.

Bad: Keyboard unbelievably uncomfortable, overall bad quality, necessity of using a stylu

Comment: Don't believe it is Sony!!! I received it as an unwanted gift. I am going to change for the other one. This time maybe htc. Or Orange San Francisco I am sure to be better that this phone.

I own it
andy_peoples's avatar
4.5 stars out of 5

andy_peoples 18 December 2008

Good: Glorious touch screen

Bad: Windows Mobile

Comment: Brilliant phone, but it needs touchflo installed to get rid of the need of a stylus. It crashes the odd time but as a first release of firmware its not as bad as my old N95 was when it first launched. The brilliant screen makes up for everything!

Torquemada's avatar
2 stars out of 5

Torquemada 28 October 2008

Good: Pannels, nice idea

Bad: You get nothing of substance for its size

Comment: Bought one this morning from Carphone Warehouse, took it straight back in the afternoon. Felt like I was using an old Ipaq pda! Apart from the "Pannels/windows" view, its the same Windows mobile - feels outdated compared to whats available now. Sluggish, screen very small, overall operaitions very fiddly. Camera very bad as is Video...Speaker sound very low and tinny (Blackberrry bold puts it to shame - in so many different areas.). Just did not understand what I was getting extra for the size of the device. There are loads more phones cheaper and can do same or better....Oh I forgot to mention, they keyboard feels too wide, and keys are too sunk in...
Good 8 months ago maybe...
You have been warned.

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should I buy it?

Sony Ericsson Xperia X1

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the Sony Ericsson Xperia X1

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2012 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.