This web site uses cookies to improve your experience. By viewing our content, you are accepting the use of cookies. To find out more and change your cookie settings, please view our cookie policy. Close

Sony Ericsson P1i review

Our rating

3.0 stars out of 5

User rating

3.5 stars out of 5

See all 11 user reviews

What do you think?

Verdict

The P1i is certainly not short on features. It has brilliant connectivity, a good range of onboard office tools and some impressive extras like its business card scanner software. The clunky user interface and weird keyboard layout, however, make it more difficult to use than competing smart phones

Typical price

£340

Good

  • Wi-Fi and 3G support
  • Good business applications
  • Good camera

Bad

  • Confusing user interface
  • Weird keyboard layout
  • Short battery life

In this review

The P1i is Sony Ericsson's latest all-singing, all-dancing smart phone that aims to keep you connected with the office while you're out on the road. It's packed with great features including support for 3G, Wi-Fi and push email.

Essentially the handset is an update of the P990i, but this new model differs in a number of ways, not least of which is the dumping of the P990i's flip-up keypad in favour of the Qwerty keyboard last seen on the company's M600i messenger phone. But let's not kid ourselves here, the P990i wasn't all that well received, so the P1i is going to have to make up a lot of lost ground if it's going to really impress us.

It's available SIM-free from eXpansys for about £370 and for free on a monthly contract with O2.

Design
Previous smart phones from Sony Ericsson have tended to be of a bulkier build, to put it politely. The P1i is still a little chunky, but it's much more in line with competing models, which means you can hold it up to your ear without feeling like a total muppet.

Unlike the older smart phones in the P series, this one does away with the flip-down keypad. Instead it's been kitted out with the same Qwerty keypad that was featured on the M600i handset. This isn't exactly a full Qwerty keyboard, though. Instead, two letters share the same key, but unlike on the Blackberry Pearl where a shift button is used to access the second letter, on this model the buttons are actually rocker switches. So to type Q you hit the key on the left side and to type W you hit it on the right side. It's an interesting approach and it's better than the Pearl's configuration, but it still takes some getting used to and it's not as good as the full keyboard used on the likes of the Palm Treo.


The P1i can be operated either by using the included stylus on the touchscreen interface, the wheel at the side or with the Qwerty keypad

If you prefer, you can always switch to the onscreen keyboard and use the stylus to tap the letters on the large touchscreen, or alternatively try out the handwriting recognition. The latter is a tad limited, though -- it can only recognise individual letters and even then it doesn't do a very good job.

Most of the phone's menus are navigated using the touchscreen, but there's also a wheel on the left-hand side that can be used to scroll through long lists. To select an item you just press the wheel and if you want to move back a step you push the button underneath it. It's all fairly straightforward stuff.

Features
The P1i is certainly not going to be caught short on the connectivity front. It packs in support for both Bluetooth and IrDA as well as Wi-Fi and 3G. The 3G support unfortunately doesn't stretch as far as HSDPA, but you do get twin cameras for video calling.

The rear-mounted camera is naturally the more interesting of the two snappers. It has a 3.2-megapixel resolution and although there's no micro-mirror for taking self-portraits, it does have autofocus and a built-in flash that's blindingly bright because it uses two LEDs. The shots it takes are above average for a camera phone -- they look pleasingly sharp and have decent colour.

The most interesting thing about the camera, however, is that Sony Ericsson has included some software on the phone that allows it to work as a business card scanner. You just start up the scanner application, take a shot of a card and then hit the process key. The phone works on the image for a few seconds and then automatically takes you to the Contacts Book where it has filled all the info into a new contact card.

  • Print

User reviews11

Add your review

igglepiggle's avatar
4.5 stars out of 5

igglepiggle 3 December 2008

Good: Almost everything - the jog dial in particular is great

Bad: The camera could be better

Comment: Admittedly, I've spent the last year tweaking and modding the phone (Opera 9.5, Fring, the W960i's Walkman player, etc.), but it's now so good that my Xperia is in the process of being sold. Once you get used to the keyboard, you'll find that it's far quicker than any touch-screen out there and far easier to use than the Xperia's monstrosity of a keyboard.
The push e-mail support for Gmail is superb, the speakerphone loud and clear, and even with heavy usage I still get a minimum of two days between charges.
The fact that you can now buy a new P1i for £150 makes it even better. If mine breaks, I'll be buying a new one straight away.

iarlakd's avatar
0.5 star out of 5

iarlakd 10 July 2008

Good: nice screen and battery life. thats about it.

Bad: slooooow. rubbish user interface. too complicated to do anything and half the. and expensive to cap it all off.

sdelong's avatar
2 stars out of 5

sdelong 24 April 2008

Good: Excellent features, doesn't crash

Bad: Extremely poor interface/operating system

Comment: I like the look and feel of this phone - it's slim and the alphanumeric keyboard works well. Battery life isn't that bad either - 2 days with heavier than average use.

Still, the more I use this phone, the less I like it. The interface is very, very poorly designed. It takes several clicks to get to an application. Applications don't close - you have to go to the task manager to do that, which is only accessible by clicking on the touchscreen's extreme upper right icon. This icon is difficult to click if you lost the stylus. It's also necessary to use the keyboard, touchscreen and side buttons to navigate around this phone. It's almost as if Sony Ericsson released a prototype.

I can't wait for my contract to end so I can get a Nokia or Iphone.

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should I buy it?

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the Sony Ericsson P1i

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2013 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.