Samsung B2100 Solid Extreme review

Our rating

2.5 stars out of 5

User rating

4.5 stars out of 5

See all 4 user reviews

What do you think?

Verdict

If you tend to break phones by dropping them, or like to chat underwater, the rugged Samsung B2100 Solid Extreme can help. But, except for its built-in torch, this inexpensive phone skimps on features

Good

  • Bash-resistant
  • Waterproof
  • Built-in torch
  • Long battery life

Bad

  • Very basic features
  • Dated user interface
  • Poor screen
  • Rubber keys are hard to press
  • No 3G

In this review

Why did we take the Samsung B2100 Solid Extreme phone to the gym, dunk it in the shower and boil it in the steam room? Numerous reasons: to time our steam, listen to music, take pictures of our feet, and even try calling a few friends. But mostly the reason was: because we could. The B2100 makes that kind of crazy stuff possible, thanks to its rugged rubber exterior and waterproof flanges.

All this ruggedness won't drain your wallet, either. The B2100 is available for free on a £15-per-month contract if you sign up for 24 months, or for about £90 SIM-free.

Tough as nails
The B2100 is compliant with the MIL-STD-810F (this should only be said in the loudest drill-sergeant voice you can muster) military standard. Samsung says it can withstand 'blowing rain, dust, shock, salt fog, humidity, water, immersion, solar radiation, vibration and extreme temperature'. That all sounds great, although we're pretty sure that 'solar radiation' just means 'sun'. Anyway, the B2100 lived up to its rating in our tests.

After making sure that the rubbery cover on the proprietary headphone socket was on, and the battery cover was locked tight, we took the B2100 for a boot-camp workout of 20 minutes in the steam room and 5 minutes in the shower. Throughout, the phone worked fine for surfing, music (without headphones, so the cover could stay closed) and calls. After we were kicked out of the gym for bringing a camera phone into the shower area, we opened the back cover and it was as dry as a bone inside.


The B2100 will appeal to rubber fetishists and those who like to talk underwater

The B2100 also has a rubbery keypad that will keep out the dirt, but it's slightly harder to use than a keyboard with independent, separated keys. We found that we had to press the keys quite hard to register our intentions, and you certainly wouldn't be able to type a text with your ski gloves on.

Back in the '90s
It's just too bad that this rugged phone can't be as attractive and modern as a normal phone. Even if you like its rubbery outside -- and we happen to love a bit of rubber -- the B2100's low-resolution, 46mm (1.8-inch) screen is unlikely to impress. The user interface makes you feel like you've stepped back in time to about 1997. If you long for the simplicity of the phones of yesteryear, you might love the straightforward user interface, but we found it dated and dull.

The features also disappoint, with just the basics on-board. These include an FM radio, a music player and a voice recorder. Everything works as it should, but, just as we'd expect on such an inexpensive phone, we were never wowed. And, with only 10MB of internal memory, you'll need to invest in a microSD memory card if you plan to take many tunes with you.

There's also a 1.3-megapixel camera, which shoots stills or video. There's a host of fun photo tweaks, such as frames that you can superimpose on your shots. There's even an image editor, so you can crop or filter photos. But, with no 3G connectivity, you won't be uploading your masterpieces to Flickr very quickly.

One feature that does set the B2100 apart -- except from its ruggedised sibling, the B2700 Bound -- is its built-in torch. It's got an incandescent bulb, and is really bright. Samsung hasn't released official figures regarding the B2100's battery life, but the battery lasted very well in our tests. After a few hours of testing, including blasting the torch for 10 minutes, the battery meter still showed a full charge.

Conclusion
The Samsung B2100 Solid Extreme is certainly solid, shrugging off our watery tests. But, other than a torch, it offers rock-bottom features to match its bargain-basement price tag. The splash-proof B2700 has a couple more features for around the same price, so, if you don't need the B2100's 1m water-resistance rating, it may be worth getting the higher-end version. But, if you're very tough on phones and you miss the simplicity and long battery life of the phone you were rocking at the turn of the millennium, the B2100 could be a good choice.

Edited by Charles Kloet

User reviews4

Add your review

coolv's avatar
4 stars out of 5

coolv 20 September 2010

Good: I use this phone as my internet modem in my computer at home and it is so fast compared to other phones.its speed is 460.8kps

Bad: The phone does not comes out with usb cable/ software.so i'm using my Samsung Star kit(cable and software)

Comment: I use this phone as my internet modem in my computer at home and it is so fast compared to other phones.its speed is 460.8kps

I own it
Marina Igorevna 'Inazuma' Muttik's avatar
5 stars out of 5

Marina Igorevna 'Inazuma' Muttik 30 August 2010

Good: Pros: Torch, waterproof, dustproof, shockproof, attractive, hardy, good features, a lifesaver.

Bad: Cons: Clunky, scratches and dents, can still get dusty.

Comment: Since i'm an avid rider, always dropping phones, etc, after breaking both previous phones while riding i thought i'd invest in a hard-wearing phone.
This phone is by far the most attractive hard wearing, waterproof, shockproof, dustproof phone on the market, and the only one of its kind with a camera.
Since buying, it has not broken, does not have a stupid screen like normal phones that you just press and it breaks, and it VERY hardy.
I have dropped into the roads many a times, drenched in rain, in a bath and a bucket, have lost in a horses stable overnight and it has so far survived.
Although, it does only have basic phone features, it is more advanced than the old nokias of the 90's, it makes for good music playing, louder than most phones available , avan being waterproof.
On the other hand, it does get scratched - mine is now covered in a wide array of marks, scratches and dents, although this may be due to the fact i throw it to people and regularly drop.
Also, although the smallest hardy phone out there, it is still rather big, so only just about fits in my jodhpur pockets, and is way too big for my phone holder.
The inbuilt torch is also a lifesaver! Walking home in the dark, losing something becomes much better with a torch, and this torch is pretty powerful for what it is.
Overall, i'd much rather this than any conventional phone, and it will probably last so much longer.

I own it
david1997's avatar
4 stars out of 5

david1997 12 August 2010

Good: It makes and receives calls. Battery life. Built for boys.

Bad: This is no smart phone.

Comment: Bought with our son's scout camp trip in mind, wanted something that would not break at the first attempt, and would not need charging during his week away. At home we use it as our 'overseas sim' phone . It will probably still be in use in 10 years time - long after my iPhone has gone to it's maker.

I own it

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should I buy it?

Samsung B2100 Solid Extreme front

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the Samsung B2100 Solid Extreme

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2012 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.