This web site uses cookies to improve your experience. By viewing our content, you are accepting the use of cookies. To find out more and change your cookie settings, please view our cookie policy. Close

LG Shine review

Our rating

3.5 stars out of 5

User rating

3 stars out of 5

See all 5 user reviews

What do you think?

Verdict

If you're looking for an eye-catching phone then the LG Shine won't disappoint. It's stylish, feels well-built and its mirrored front section is great for checking yourself out in. But, as with the Chocolate phone, this phone is focused on fashion -- the feature set might disappoint you if you're looking for a high-tech gadget

Good

  • Mirrored front section
  • Metal casing
  • Expandable memory slot
  • World clock

Bad

  • Mirrored section gets dirty easily
  • Keypad
  • Camera looks dated compared with the competition

In this review

The LG Shine is one of the most desirable phones we've seen, thanks to the gleaming metal and mirrored front. If you're looking for a phone with a touch of class, then this should be near the top of your list.

Available soon for free with a contract, the LG Shine is a rare example of a fashion phone that's actually useable.

Design
The first thing you'll notice when you take the LG Shine out of its box is that there's a mirror where you'd expect the screen to be, and it's large enough to quickly check yourself out before a big meeting or a hot date. Turn the phone on, though, and you'll realise there's actually a large colour screen beneath the reflective surface -- it's a really cool effect.

Unfortunately, as soon as you start to use the phone you'll realise what a grease and fingerprint magnet the screen is. It's annoying, but it's also part of the Shine's charm -- it's all about style over practicality. The glass front looks incredible when it's clean; just be prepared to clean it a lot.

Unlike many phones that feel like toys made from cheap plastic, the Shine feels strong and well built. It's slightly heavier than most phones we've seen recently, but this only adds to the sensation that you've got a quality product in your hand. At only 14mm thick, it slips easily into a pocket.

The materials used in the LG Shine remind us of other classy mobiles like the Nokia 8800. The metal casing oozes quality, and when you look at the back, where the 2-megapixel camera is housed, it looks more like a cutting-edge, ultra-compact digital camera than a phone.

When you push the top section up, the flat, Razr-like keypad is unveiled, the screen is activated and a blue backlight illuminates the keys, including the two soft keys at the top. Annoyingly, you invariably touch the mirrored glass section to open the phone, smearing it with your mucky paws.

The sliding mechanism is superb. There's none of the wobbling or shaking we've seen on some rival phones when sliding it open or shut, and it feels very sturdy compared with the majority of other slider phones.

Once opened, you use a bar that you scroll up and down to navigate the menu, which can be slow-going at times. Unlike, say, the iPod's Click Wheel, which lets you scroll without taking your thumb off the wheel, you need to keep lifting your thumb off the Shine's scroll bar to keep scrolling. The scrolling speed is also a little slow and you can't adjust it, which is a shame.

The Shine's keypad is completely flat, so it can be difficult to work out which key is which, and it suffers from the usual slider phone problem of a lack of space for the bottom row of keys.

Features
The large colour screen is surprisingly bright, even though it's hidden behind the reflective surface, and it works well as a viewfinder for the camera.

  • Print

User reviews5

Add your review

skyfyre's avatar
0.5 star out of 5

skyfyre 12 June 2009

Good: The mirror's the best part of the entire product. Which isn't good if it's a phone.

Bad: Awful design, awful functionality, can't be used as a phone outdoors quite often, LG isn't standing behind it. LG C Service guy recommended I bin it.

Comment: Horrible design - although it looks nice, the looks certainly get in the way of its functionality, which is actually a terrible way to design things! It interferes rendering the phone useless. Plus the internal design mapping is nonsensical and inflexible.

I regret purchasing this phone. My screen craked (or had a 'bleeding lcd crystal') without any pressure or knock to the phone. In under a year it had 2 batteries. If there is sunshine outdoors - don't even try to use your phone. Because you can't. You honestly CAN'T SEE THE SCREEN! All you see is the mirror!

I've complained to the company directly and to the retailer and they have been nothing but rude and uncaring (and denying there is anything wrong with it, when all they have to do is take it outside if there's any sun). Rubbish phone, rubbish company. This was my 2nd - and final - chance with an LG product and I was upset with both items. STAY AWAY FROM LG OR YOU'LL REGRET WASTING YOUR MONEY!

LG Customer Service guy recommended I bin it. I am dead serious.

Hundog's avatar
4.5 stars out of 5

Hundog 23 November 2007

Good: The whole phone

Bad: Java turn off.

Comment: Actually I have a LG TU720 SHINE which is way better... quad band, 5 way joystick... I have no clue why they made two phones?!
All in all the Shine is really slick and has all the nneded features.
Go for it!

pageheaven's avatar
4.5 stars out of 5

pageheaven 30 September 2007

Good: The style, The screen, The extras included in box, The GUI interface, The Sleekness, The price

Bad: Scroll wheel

Comment: Man this site is slow!! Anyhow, loved this phone from when I got it, to when I traded it in for a Sony Ericsson W950i.
Unfourtunatly this pic provided does the phone no justice, as mine were brushed silver colour. This phone does everything on the box really, but there were things which suprised me - The phone felt cold everytime I held it due to the metal (Which I happen to like), it had good weight to it, it were sleek, amd the interface looked fantastic!!

If you are into music playback on your phone, like myself, you'll love this hardware - Same for design.

Box includes: Handset, Stylish Headphones, Suede Pouch, USB Cable, Drivers/Software Disc, Instructions Booklet etc...


Very affordable, a must buy!!

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should I buy it?

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the LG Shine

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2013 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.