Ad: Get our free CNET Android app

Best video phones

Hollywood is dead. The paparazzi, yogic healers, pet psychiatrists and cosmetic surgeons might not realise it yet (even if Beyonce and Lady Gaga already have), but everything you need for real film-making can now fit in the palm of your hand. Today's movie-mad mobiles can shoot hours of video (sometimes in high definition), edit it down and launch you to stardom on YouTube or Flickr.

But just as the same LA studio that made Inception is also responsible for Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore 3D, some video phones are great while others are simply rubbish.

If you're serious about mobile movies, start with a phone's imaging system. High definition alone isn't a recipe for success, but there's no point handicapping yourself with old-school VGA (640x480-pixel) clips unless you're seriously short of storage space or cash. Wannabe directors should seek out 720 or full 1080-line capture for brighter, sharper video.

Pay just as much attention to the maximum frame rate. Clips shot at 15 frames per second (fps) will look noticeably jerky compared with the cinematic standard of 24fps or butter-smooth 30fps. A few phones offer ultra-fast 120fps to give (slightly gimmicky) slow-mo playback.

Autofocus is generally a good idea but it depends on how smart it is. It's easier to watch fixed-focus footage that gets a little blurry up close than autofocus clips where the phone is constantly hunting back and forth.

Unlike a real camcorder, you haven't got a zoom lens or optical stabilisation to help your camera crew. A high-speed mode for action and high-sensitivity mode for night-time shooting will be worth their weight in celluloid, and an LED video light is simply invaluable. You can't expect much more in the way of features, although face detection and colour effects are common.

Editing widgets are likely to be very basic -- if you can do more than trim clips and dub a soundtrack you should be feeling very smug. As you'd expect, smart phones do much better here, but even the best apps pale in comparison with almost any desktop software. This is one area where the limited processing power of phones is painfully obvious.

In terms of build, mechanical shutter and zoom buttons are always better than fiddling with touchscreen icons. Any reasonably sharp screen at 63.5mm (2.5 inches) or larger will be fine for framing and shooting but you might want more real estate for playing back. Bear in mind that shooting video is the most power-draining activity you can do on your phone, especially if you're geotagging clips. Choose a handset with a hefty battery life, and keep your charger handy.

Storage quickly becomes an issue if you're shooting in HD. Internal memory is fine but nothing beats an easily accessible microSD card slot. The cards are dirt cheap these days and will make swapping and downloading a breeze. If you can find one of the few handsets to boast a mini-HDMI port, they're great for instant flat-screen telly playback. Otherwise, DLNA over Wi-Fi makes it fairly easy to stream clips using your home network.

Here are some light action cameras from the CNET UK team to whet your creative appetite.

Editors:

4.0 stars out of 5

Users:

3.5 stars out of 5

Apple iPhone 4

Even though it’s now over a year old, Apple's iPhone 4 remains a fantastic device. The introduction of iOS 5 makes it even better, but if you can afford the additional expense, then it’s worth at least considering the superior iPhone 4S. Read more

Monthly deals from £18.50

Reviewed on 7 June 2010

Editors:

4.0 stars out of 5

Users:

4.75 stars out of 5

Motorola Milestone XT720

The XT720 isn't perfect, and a few flaws stop it from being the best Android smart phone out there. Its brilliant camera and range of features mean it's still an excellent phone in its own right. Read more

Monthly deals from £10.50

Reviewed on 12 August 2010

Editors:

4.0 stars out of 5

Users:

3.15 stars out of 5

Sony Ericsson Xperia X10

A decent camera and beautiful screen are just the beginning for the Sony Ericsson Xperia X10, which is packed with juicy hardware features. The software's not bad either, although it doesn't quite live up to the latest smart phones, due to an older version of the Android OS and custom apps that are more about the sizzle than the sausage Read more

Monthly deals from £13.50

Reviewed on 14 April 2010

Editors:

4.5 stars out of 5

Users:

4.2 stars out of 5

HTC Desire

HTC has packed every feature under the sun into the Desire, along with a slick user interface and plenty of processing power. Although not as sexy as the HTC Legend or as polished as the iPhone, the Desire is a smart phone that inspires lust Read more

Monthly deals from £10.50

Reviewed on 29 March 2010

Comments 2

Add your comment

Fongy's avatar

Fongy 17 September, 2010 15:57

This is utter rubbish - these are exactly the same 4 phones they quoted as "best camera phones" - no mention of the Galaxy S and it's AMAZING HD video taking abilities...

CNET is turning into utter rubbish... it really is... I love the way in every article they completely sl@g off itunes and how "disgustingly slow" it is - but still give it 4.5/5 - soooooooo obviously bias...

Recently rating PS MOVE on the basis of its starting line-up and not the actual technology itself...

Time to move on from CNET...

Anonymous's avatar

Anonymous 17 October, 2010 15:41

These phone reviews are rubbish, its the same phones in each of your catergories. CNET you need to sack the reviewer(s). He / she is utter rubbish!

Post your comment

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Your email will not be displayed with your comment

Copy the letters and numbers to prove that you're human. You won't have to do this if you log in or register

Your comment must comply with the Terms of Use

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2012 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.