Putting a camera on a mobile phone was the best idea since piping icing onto a cake. Nowadays, more photos are taken on mobiles than all the stand-alone cameras in the world put together -- but the sad truth is that a lot of them are still blurred, dull and grainy.
It's hardly surprising. Most phone cameras sport a lens the size of a drawing pin and photo modes that have more in common with the original Box Brownie than today's digital SLRs. But there are some excellent exceptions, and finding them is easy if you know what to look for.
Although resolution isn't the be-all and end-all of digital photography, it indicates how seriously a phone maker takes imaging. Mobiles with a 5-megapixel resolution or higher tend to have more and better features than their low-res brethren. These produce pictures big enough to print at up to A4 in size -- that's plenty for a mobile snap. But don't think that more megapixels is always better.
Jumping up to 8 or 10 megapixels can increase digital 'noise' without visibly improving detail. Factors such as the quality of the lens and size of the sensor will then determine whether you get awesome or awful shots.
HTC took a bold move in plonking only a 4-megapixel snapper onto its flagship phone. It claims, however, that the individual pixels are bigger, resulting in better image quality overall. That might sound like marketing nonsense, but I can't deny I was impressed with the images.
Auto-focusing is an absolute must. Look out for a macro mode for really sharp close-ups. Some camera phones come with all manner of specialist scene modes but, honestly, how often will you really select 'food' or 'museum' mode before hitting the shutter? More useful are easy, one-touch overrides such as exposure compensation for highlights or shadows, and spot-focusing to concentrate on your main subject.
The other essential is an LED -- or, preferably, a xenon -- flash. LED lights are fine for illuminating a single person or nearby object but a proper xenon flash, like the ones found on dedicated cameras, will punch out enough photons to light up an entire room. Be warned, though: these can really munch through your battery.
Other features worth looking out for are face detection, intelligent exposure, high dynamic range, automatic panoramas, 'smile shutters' and burst modes. You might not find yourself using them often, but they're likely to come in handy.
If you want a seemingly endless set of features and camera tricks, check out the Galaxy S4. Its vast selection of camera additions, while not exactly crucial to the phone, will certainly help you create some wacky shots to jazz up your Facebook page.
Some of these features can be neat, but there's something to be said for simplicity too -- just having lots of features and options doesn't make a camera phone great. In some cases, quite the opposite. Some of the best camera phones -- such as the iPhone 5, which has a paltry set of shooting options -- are able to strip away unnecessary complexity and zero in on producing reliable results in a variety of conditions.
When it comes to screens, quality is more important than raw size. Look for displays of 4 inches or more, so you can comfortably compose your shots without the camera software or your fingers getting in the way. The higher the screen resolution the better too -- to give you the best chance of determining whether the shot you just snapped was in focus or not.
Storage is another consideration -- some phones offer a microSD card slot so you can easily expand the amount of space you have to save your shots. Smart phones can also be set up to automatically upload photos to cloud storage or social networks such as Dropbox or Google+ -- a handy way to keep snaps backed up.
Phones with built-in GPS should automatically geo-tag your photos with their location, and of course there are bags of photography-related apps to fill any feature gaps. There are apps out there to stitch together panoramas, add visual effects, edit your photos on your mobile and even replicate old-style film cameras. Apple's iOS and Google's Android both offer an extensive collection of apps to augment your camera experience.
If you plan on editing all your snaps before sending them off to your Twitter followers, you'll find a speedier phone -- with a dual- or quad-core processor -- better for you. You'll spend less time waiting for filters to apply and your phone is less likely to become overwhelmed and force-close the app.
Focus in on the latest camera phones with CNET UK reviews -- here are a handful of the best to get you started, in no particular order.
You should also have a gander at our comparison tests for some excellent examples of these phones' pics. Here's how the Galaxy S4 stacks up against the HTC One, iPhone 5, Xperia Z and Lumia 920. We've also tested how the iPhone 5 compares to the Samsung Galaxy S3 and HTC One X, and how today's best camera phones measure up to the innovative Samsung Galaxy Camera.
Additional writing by Mark Harris and Natasha Lomas.
Comments 20
Add your comment
Anonymous 13 October, 2010 23:01
I wish they'd put a mobile phone on a dedicated camera .. that I would buy.
If you look at the camera part of these devices (ie take away the pda and pretty screens and just look at the camera) - well you're left underwhelmed.
Give me a dedicated camera with a phone bolted onto it .. GSM is fine thank you. A compact digital would be nice
Anonymous 13 October, 2010 23:01
I wish they'd put a mobile phone on a dedicated camera .. that I would buy.
If you look at the camera part of these devices (ie take away the pda and pretty screens and just look at the camera) - well you're left underwhelmed.
Give me a dedicated camera with a phone bolted onto it .. GSM is fine thank you. A compact digital would be nice
Anonymous 27 October, 2010 23:16
Nokia N8...good camera, poor quality speaker if it is use when making or reviving a call. touch-screen very difficult to use.
Nokia make good phones but can not improve customer care. Try to return a phone brought online or by phone from Nokia. It is achievable if you are willing to wait more than 3 hours for anyone to take a decision.
and BE CAREFUL you are not dealing with Nokia in UK, you also are dealing with 2020 Mobiles with a very different TERMS AND CONDITIONS, after you finish with them, you should have to wait for few hours or days for someone to call you back and advise you to call any of the other subsidiary of Nokia to approve the return before the 14 days.
Anonymous 5 November, 2010 11:06
Where is Nokia N8 - it's better than these recommendations...
Anonymous 7 November, 2010 22:37
These phones arent really very good camera phones but good phones with cameras. Where is the nokia N8? the SE c905? Vivaz? Even the damn Satio!
tomg 21 December, 2010 22:40
n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8 n8
carl zeis lense 12 megapixl where is the n8
Anonymous 24 July, 2011 13:55
Surely it can't be TOO difficult to build a phone into a proper digital camera.
anonymous 5 July, 2012 16:30
where is the s3?????
anonymous 13 July, 2012 12:29
I agree with the last comment...where indeed is the Samsung Galaxy S3?!?!
This is a half ar$ed review if I say so....I have an S3 and have been using for about a month now
Excellent battery life even when you do heavily use the camera! Much better than my HTC desire and the battery is changeable too...can the HTX one X or the iphone 4s do that...NO!
The s3 comes with 16Gb SD card.....can the HTC or iphone use an SD card?.....no again I believe?!?
I used my S3 at an airshow recently as I didn't want to keep swapping lenses on my Canon SLR and I was very impressed with the shots of both static and moving subjects
anonymous 17 August, 2012 14:56
where is arc s?? the best cameraphone 2011??
anonymous 31 August, 2012 00:06
i thought this article was about the best camera on phones..the stupidity on cnet..
anonymous 26 October, 2012 14:51
4star for ip4 is extremely generous! I currently have one and the camera is the biggest disapointment of it (hence looking at this thread). If your target is moving it blurs ridiculously and if your shooting from a distance it adds a ghost effect, turn off the HD and its not much better.
Can anyone link a proper review on CAMERA phones?
anonymous 16 January, 2013 20:11
ClipClock is an amazing social video hub and sharing app!Check it out: www.clipclock.com/download/4295
dorix 23 January, 2013 09:27
This was headed "Best camera phone" I believe, So why, in this article, is it saying about the OS. It is a well known fact that the 808Pureview has a better lens and sensor than even some DSLRs and certainly better than a lot of compacts.
anonymous 24 February, 2013 08:58
This article was more about OS's and battery than about the Camera.
I found the article, was really interested to read it. Sadly I concluded the author was more against this or that OS / Phone than the finding the right camera.
Finally, anyone who has done any research knows how ordinary the Nexus 4 camera is.
to give it a 4.5 rating puts CNET's street cred in the gutter.
Come on guys at least try to be objective...
anonymous 4 March, 2013 21:52
Please ? most of my photo's are at night, What camera is best
and with a powerful flash, As for the phone ! I just need A PHONE.
anonymous 15 May, 2013 12:51
Before i began to read this, i knew the S4 was going get the most attention.
Matt Winston. 15 May, 2013 13:32
@ Above Comment
No, the S4 hasn't got most of the attention. You haven't read the article at all have you?
anonymous 15 May, 2013 14:16
@anonymous 12:51 Well that's one way of making yourself look like a total idiot!
anonymous 16 May, 2013 16:32
oh my!! i cannot believe no one has mentioned the Nokia 808 Pureview...Anyone who is into photography will be amazed by this 41 megapixel lens..its voted the most advanced camera in a phone to date & unmatched by any iphone5 or samsung s4. Its a 5 yr in the making lens that's why it has a hump on its back..you cant sacrifice hardware for software...even audio has HAAC technology (high amplitude audio capture)...check out youtube videos about it and smartphone cam photo comparissons just to prove my point...the only con is the OS which is the last symbian by Nokia..i doubt if anyone would dare prove me wrong...