Apple MacBook Pro (17-inch) review

In this review

The 17-inch MacBook Pro comes in one default configuration that costs £1,899. Though there aren't a lot of upgrade options, our review unit included RAM and hard drive enhancements that brought the price up to £2,099. For that much money, you'd expect some pretty high-end specs, and the MacBook delivers -- it has a fast, 2.16GHz Intel Core Duo processor, 2GB of speedy 667MHz DDR2 RAM, an ATI Mobility Radeon X1600 graphics card with 256MB of VRAM, and a blazing 7,200rpm, 100GB hard drive. Still, the MacBook Pro is a bit more expensive than similarly configured Windows laptops.

Performance
CNET Labs compared the 17-inch MacBook Pro to a number of older Apple laptops running the PowerPC processor as well as other Core Duo-based Macs. Unsurprisingly, the MacBook Pro trailed behind a PowerBook G4 when running Sorenson Squeeze, which requires the Rosetta translation program to run on the new chipset. But its ample amount of RAM and quick hard drive helped it power through our Photoshop CS test, in spite of Rosetta. (We expect the MacBook Pro's performance to even out once software publishers release more so-called universal binary apps -- however, we recommend checking if your applications are or will soon be Intel-compatible before buying any new Apple system.)

Of course, on native applications such as iTunes, the 17-inch MacBook Pro saw significant gains over the previous generation of PowerBooks. Probably due to its discrete graphics card, the 17-inch MacBook Pro displayed very respectable Doom 3 frame rates, though its 23.2 frames per second (fps) can't compete with the 56.5fps achieved by the Inspiron E1705 we tested. In our DVD battery-drain test, the MacBook Pro lasted 2 hours, 54 minutes -- quite respectable for a desktop replacement that's not likely to see too much time away from the wall socket.  

Photoshop CS
(Shorter bars indicate faster performance)
MacBook Pro 17-inch (Tested 5/06)
7.68 
MacBook Pro Core Duo 2GHz (OS 10.4.6) (Tested 4/06)
9.15 
PowerBook G4 1.5GHz 12-inch (Tested 8/05)
10.3 
iBook G4 1.33GHz 12-inch (Tested 8/05)
12.9 
MacBook Core Duo 2GHz (OS 10.4.6) (Tested 5/06)
16.9 


Doom 3 (frames per second)
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
MacBook Pro 17-inch (Tested 5/06)
23.2 
MacBook Pro Core Duo 2GHz (OS 10.4.6) (Tested 4/06)
15.3 
MacBook Core Duo 2GHz (OS 10.4.6) (Tested 5/06) No AA enabled
4.5 
PowerBook G4 1.5GHz 12-inch (Tested 8/05)
3.8 
 

Sorenson (in minutes)
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)
PowerBook G4 1.5GHz 12-inch (Tested 8/05)
8.15 
MacBook Pro 17-inch (Tested 5/06)
23.16 
MacBook Pro Core Duo 2GHz (OS 10.4.6) (Tested 4/06)
25 
MacBook Core Duo 2GHz (OS 10.4.6) (Tested 5/06)
25.5 

 

User reviews4

Add your review

Dilbert Parton's avatar
2 stars out of 5

Dilbert Parton 21 June 2006

Good: Slim design, screen

Bad: Average performance, gets pretty hot if the battery is charging while you're using the laptop, virtually no native software yet.

Comment: Performance-wise the only thing this laptop does fast is switch on/off. It's quick but not fast. Seeing as practically every application needs to go through Rosetta the emulation takes its tax cut on performance. My desktop PC (Pentium 4 3.2GHz, 1GB RAM) out-performs this laptop at everything (apart from starting up and shutting down). I have the 2.16Hz 17-inch model with 7,200rpm disk and 1GB RAM.

Wagner Matos's avatar
4.5 stars out of 5

Wagner Matos 19 June 2006

Good: Fantastic design! It's not only beautiful, but very, very practical in all ways

Bad: Nothing really

Comment: I was a Windows user and I could't be happier with the switch! The machine delivers everything I wanted and more! Plus it has a sexy looking design (according to PC user friend of mine) and it is Apple! I've never been so happy in using a product before. Apple's support when I needed them (as a newbie I was pretty much lost!) was fantastic and I couldn't expect more.

Paul Collins's avatar
4.5 stars out of 5

Paul Collins 15 June 2006

Good: Bright screen scrolling trackpad

Bad: I would have liked a black one

Comment: If you love Macs this is the best yet, with the Boot Camp Windows option it gives everyone a chance to use quality hardware with what ever operating system they need. A stunning laptop

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should you buy it?

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the Apple MacBook Pro (17-inch)

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2012 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.