Desktop-replacement laptops
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Rory Reid
Last updated: 05 Apr 2006
Desktop-replacement laptops are a great alternative to owning a full-sized PC. They have the advantage of being portable (or at least luggable) and many of the latest models offer performance in line with the fastest desktop PCs.
The most important consideration when choosing a desktop replacement is probably screen size. You'll need to ensure it has a large display if you intend to use it in the long-term, so plump for a 17-inch or 19-inch model, as anything smaller could be quite uncomfortable. For extra flexibility you should consider the Samsung M70, which has a detachable 19-inch screen. This has its own stand, which raises the monitor to a more readable height.
Next you'll need to ensure the laptop provides enough performance to cope with everyday tasks. It's always a good idea to opt for a slightly faster laptop than you think you may need, as performing a future upgrade won't be straightforward.
Some desktop replacement laptops use components you'd normally find in full-size PCs. Many, for example, use desktop processors, but although these are very fast, they have the disadvantage of being noisy and hot, and will invariably be a huge drain on your battery. Laptops with dedicated laptop CPUs tend to be slightly slower, but they have fewer of these downsides. If possible, try to buy a laptop with a dual-core processor, as these provide excellent performance and are usually more power-efficient. The Asus A7J is a great example of this.
Laptops have recently come of age with their graphics-processing abilities. They can now rival dedicated desktop gaming PCs thanks to the advent of fast mobile graphics processing units (GPUs), and some models now have dual graphics cards for running the most demanding of games. As a rule, keen gamers should ensure their chosen laptop has a screen with a high enough resolution to take advantage of these fast GPUs.
One area often overlooked is connectivity. Some laptops have as few as three USB ports, so you'll have to do some cable juggling if you have lots of peripherals. The Dell Inspiron 9400 is a great solution for USB junkies, as it has a whopping six ports.

Compare Products
![]() Samsung M70 |
![]() Asus A7J |
![]() rockdirect Xtreme 64 |
![]() Dell Inspiron 9300 |
|
| Review date | 3 Apr 06 | 16 Feb 06 | 20 Jan 06 | 4 May 05 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £1,750 | £1,399 | £2,468 | |
| Review summary | The M70 is an enormous laptop, which you'll never want anywhere near your lap. Despite this, its ingenious detachable 19-inch screen is a joy to use, and while its performance is only average, it belies its girth to deliver stunning battery life. If you're after a laptop that can function as a true replacement for an ordinary desktop PC, there are few that challenge the M70 Read full review |
Its paltry hard drive lets it down, but the A7J excels in most other areas. Multimedia enthusiasts will love its Media Center operating system and solid performance, and its gaming abilities should appeal to anyone who's not averse to a quick bout of Battlefield 2 Read full review |
The Extreme 64 doesn't just hold its own against high-performance desktops, it can outmuscle many of them. But its use of desktop components means it produces substantial noise and heat, and being quite heavy, it's hard to take on the road. If you're prepared to pay the price of portability to get the ultimate in laptop performance, then it's a good investment Read full review |
The Dell Inspiron 9300 packs advanced multimedia features and blazing performance for gaming and home or business applications. It's fast, furious and hard as nails Read full review |
| User rating | ||||
| Clock speed | 2 GHz | 1.83 GHz | 2.4 GHz | 2.13 GHz |
| Processor type | Pentium M 755 | Core Duo T2400 | Athlon 64 X2 4800+ | Pentium M |
| Processor manufacturer | Intel | Intel | AMD | Intel |
| RAM installed | 1024 MB | 1024 MB | 1024 MB | 256 MB |
| Hard drive size | 100 GB | 60 GB | 200 GB | 40 GB |
| CD / DVD type | TEAC DV-W28EA | TSSTCorp TS-L532u | 8x Dual Layer | DVD-ROM |
| Display diagonal size | 19 in. | 17 in. | 17 in. | 17 in. |
| Dimensions (W x H x D) | 435x314x39mm | 405x35x314mm | 397x50x298mm | 394x41x287mm |
| Weight | 4.4 kg | 3.95 kg | 5.5 kg | 4.3 kg |
| Estimated battery life (mfr) | n/a | 4 hours | n/a | 3.4 hours |
| Full specification | Full specification | Full specification | Full specification |
Want to compare other products?
You can choose up to four products to compare on the Compare Products page






