Ian Morris
Ian Morris loves televisions so much he's been banned from wedding chapels in Las Vegas for trying to marry them. When he's not romancing technology, he can be found watching American TV. Ian likes roast potatoes, but he doesn't like digital rights management.
Thursday 11 October 2007, 12:28pm
Recording industry ruins single mother
Okay, I don't know for sure if Jammie Thomas's life is ruined, but I suspect at the very least she's having a bad month. The jury in her trial, where she faced the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), determined that she was guilty of possessing 24 songs -- although the RIAA claimed she shared more than 1,700 tracks -- and was fined $9,250 (£4,500) per song.
The total cost with legal fees is very likely to be nearly $250,000 (£123,000). Can you imagine being faced with a debt like that? You probably won't be surprised to learn that the verdict reduced Thomas to tears. Her lawyer said she stood to lose a quarter of her paychecks for the rest of her life to pay the fine.
I'm not interested in whether she had the music on her computer, or whether she shared it via Kazaa -- honestly, if she used Kazaa that should be considered punishment enough. I'm certainly not going to defend breaking copyright law, because it's reasonable for artists to make money from their work. What I'm bothered by is the concept that someone can be saddled with an enormous debt for a crime like this.
Generally speaking, I find the music industry's attitude towards this kind of crime despicable. There is no level to which they won't stoop to grab a couple of pennies, usually from those who can afford it least -- like children, people without computers, the elderly or the dead.
There are a couple of important lessons to learn here. Firstly, if you get sued, don't contest it and plead 'not guilty', because you'll end up poor for the rest of your life. Secondly, you'd get a much less severe sentence for stealing a few CDs.
Articles by Ian Morris
Opinion: Apple owes Microsoft $30bn
Crave Yes, that's right. Apple owes Microsoft for its success -- big time. Join us as we run you through the argument
TiVo to make triumphant return to UK with Virgin Media
Crave You might think you know what a PVR is, but in the UK we're really stuck in the past with our digital recording antics. Happily, Virgin Media is bringing TiVo back
Terminator Salvation Blu-ray: The movie isn't the worst thing on this disc
Crave This weekend, we watched Terminator Salvation, which wasn't as bad as we were expecting, but we certainly didn't enjoy the process of persuading the disc to play
How to survive a zombie attack using consumer electronics
Photo Like it or not, zombies are coming and probably sooner than you think. Good news though -- we all have tech in our homes that can be used to defeat them, so let's find out how
Technology that's totally impossible
Photo Many things in this world don't make any sense. The popularity of Miley Cyrus is one pertinent example, but some technology is so bizarre that we refuse to believe in it
Seesmic Desktop for Windows: Better for Twitter than TweetDeck?
Crave This weekend Seesmic Desktop for Windows was released. We rushed to download our copy -- we've had enough of Adobe Air munching through our system memory
BBC: We may do 1080p on Freeview HD
Crave We've been trying to find out which format BBC HD would use on Freeview for some time now -- we were surprised to learn the service could use 1080p
Philips Cinema 21:9 (56PFL9954H/12)
Review If you're a movie lover with deep pockets, the Philips Cinema 21:9 is unlikely to disappoint, offering a truly immersive way to enjoy films shot in the 2.35:1 aspect ratio in the comfort of your couch. Its great picture quality and fantastic audio are also complemented by a lovely design and plenty of features
