This web site uses cookies to improve your experience. By viewing our content, you are accepting the use of cookies. To find out more and change your cookie settings, please view our cookie policy. Close

Monster iBeats by Dr Dre review

Our rating

3.5 stars out of 5

User rating

2.5 stars out of 5

See all 8 user reviews

What do you think?

Verdict

They look great and, while the sound quality doesn't blow our minds, the Monster iBeats by Dr Dre would make an ideal upgrade from the default headphones that accompany new iPurchases.

Good

  • Great design
  • Keep their cool at high volumes
  • Decent sound quality

Bad

  • Not the clearest sound around
  • Liable to dislodge in your ears

Recently we reviewed the Beats Pro headphones -- monster cans from, er, Monster that rattled our eyeballs clean out of our skulls. They were huge, and cost over £300. Happily, those looking to permanently impair their hearing also have the choice of these -- the Monster iBeats by Dr Dre in-ear headphones. They cost a much more palatable £80, giving them great I-just-bought-an-iPod-and-I-need-something-better-than-these-horrible-white-earbuds upgrade potential. But are they worth it? We'd better review 'em and find out.

Engine of war

The headphones themselves look pretty tasty. Each 'bud puts us in mind of a very tiny turbine engine. Ours came in a tasteful black finish, but chrome, black and black-aluminium versions are also available. Whatever colour you opt for, there's a strip of red that surrounds the back of each bud, forming the Beats 'b' logo.

One bud has a blue strip around the front, while the other has a red strip, which looks cool, and might help you remember which is left and which is right (though little 'L' and 'R' symbols are also stamped on). Ultimately, this detail will be obscured by the side of your face. All things considered, though, these are well-designed, distinctive-looking headphones.

There's no fancy earloop involved in getting these things inside your head -- simply stick 'em in. There are upsides and downsides here. On the one hand, there's no faffing about tying your arms up in loops trying to get the things on. Pop them in and away you go. On the other hand, these are pretty weighty earbuds, so they don't always stay securely in your ears. The brutal power of gravity may well cause them to slide out over time -- a loop would've solved that.

If you're using an iDevice that supports phone calls, part way down the red cabling there's a remote with two volume keys, a 'call answer' button and a microphone around the other side, so you can take calls without removing your phone from your pocket. Lots of headphones offer this feature, but it's still pretty useful.

Sound reasoning

So how do the iBeats actually sound? Well... reasonable is the answer. These mini buds aren't a patch on the larger, more expensive Beats cans, but they sound on par with other headphones in their price range.

Beats are famous for their low-end kick, and while these buds deliver a decent thump, they won't liquify your eyeballs (our benchmark for technological excellence across the board). Listening to Pendulum's The Tempest, we felt every kick drum, especially as we cranked up the volume, but there's not a great deal of clarity in the low end, so things can sound slightly muddy.

What the iBeats do achieve is a nicely balanced sound -- we never noticed the bass obscuring too much of the mix in general. Listening to Bad Romance by Lady Gaga, mid-tone sounds such as the persistent grimy synth and the vocals themselves never became too noisy or overly loud.

Indeed, these buds perform well at high volume. Where we'd see many headphones losing their grip and introducing distortion, the iBeats keep everything more or less in check, which leaves you free to jump up and down on your bed singing along freely.

You won't be able to pick out every minor hi-hat tinkle and cymbal sizzle with these headphones, but for that kind of clarity you're looking at more high-end cans anyway.

Conclusion

You might find headphones for around the same price that offer similar or better sound quality, but it has to be said -- with these headphones you're also buying into the brand, and the style. The distinctive red cabling will make an impression even if most of these buds stay hidden inside your lugs or beneath your beautiful flowing locks. With reasonable sound quality, these buds are an attractive proposition, and a decent upgrade from the default white Apple headphones that plague every new iPurchase.

If you fancy something with more loops and less sheen, but arguably better sound quality, check out the lovely Sennheiser OCX 880s

Edited by Emma Bayly 

  • Print

User reviews8

Add your review

MickciM's avatar
2 stars out of 5

MickciM 5 February 2013

Good: Styling, cable quality, solid metal earbuds, lots of added rubber tips to fit your ears

Bad: Generally bad sound quality, quite flimsy remote control, remote control only partially works on Android devices

Comment: I first got these about a year back from now, and I just wanted to share my opinions on it.

-The Good-

Well, obviously, these earbuds look quite appealing. The earbuds themselves are made from aluminium, with the Beats logo on it. The cable is sleek and red, which looks great, but unfortunately it is not tangle-free. What I also noticed, is that Beats stated there was no cable noise when having the earbuds in. I must say that this is not entirely true, since I can clearly hear the noise of the cable when I, for example, tug on it. However, build quality doesn't really seem to be lacking here. Also, the earbuds come with various rubber eartips to perfectly suit your ears. I found the large "christmas tree" tip to be the most comfortable.

- The Bad-
Well, right off the bat I was very disappointed with the sound quality when I first plugged these into my computer. The overall sound was muffled and unbalanced, with a very clear lack of highs, and it just generally sounded like trash, especially with stuff like hardrock, instrumental music, et cetera. The remote control also isn't very stylish, it looks like something right out of a Star Trek movie.

-Bottom Line-

I strongly disrecommend these earbuds for buyers who crave clear, balanced sound.

I own it
Sebastian Cargill's avatar
2 stars out of 5

Sebastian Cargill 6 March 2012

Good: sound

Bad: poor build quality

Comment: I got these but they broke in around 2 months. Also they are really heavy so fall out your ears easily. But they do have decent sound quality

I own it
MastaHaze3721's avatar
5 stars out of 5

MastaHaze3721 9 February 2012

Good: Clear sound, Crisp Highs, Mids weren't muffled, Heavy (not overwhelming) bass

Bad: Lack of ribbon cording

Comment: IMO these are the single best in-ear headphones by Beats by Dre. They offer far superior sound quality to any other in-ear headphones I have ever used (and that's loads). I believe they run for around $99 (US) and 80 (UK).

I recommend these to everyone who enjoys music and wants to get the most out of a pair of headphones. As for where to buy them, Everything Beats is your best bet. I don't believe that they are currently offering a discount on the iBeats (they tend to have very nice discounts on most Beats products), but I can guarantee you that they will not disappoint.

http://everythingbeats.com

I own it

Tell us what you think

Log in with your CNET UK or Facebook account to post a user review, or click Join to create an account

Step 1

0 out of 5

Step 2

Submit

Please log in, register or login with Facebook to add a review or comment

Should I buy it?

Monster iBeats by Dr Dre

Ask your Facebook friends and Twitter followers if you should buy the Monster iBeats by Dr Dre

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2013 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.