Handhelds Buying Guide

SHOULD I CHOOSE PALM OR WINDOWS MOBILE 2003?

For years, these two handheld operating systems have competed fiercely to woo handheld buyers. Both do an admirable job with the core applications: address book, calendar, to-do list and memos. And since the release of Palm OS 5.0, they're nearly evenly matched in terms of processors, screen resolutions and multimedia functions. There are, however, still some key differences.

Palm OS 5.0 | Windows Mobile 2003

Palm OS 5.0

With the release of OS 5.0, the Palm operating system made some major improvements yet retained its ease of use. The new multithreading OS supports ARM-based processors, which keeps Palm competitive with Windows Mobile 2003 products by increasing overall computing performance and enhancing multimedia features.

To input letters and numbers, Palm uses Graffiti 2.0, an updated version of its original handwriting recognition system, where you write in block characters that are similar to traditional letters, but easier for the handheld to recognise.

Many Palm OS devices still have a designated Graffiti area below the display, which limits the screen size. Newer models offer a virtual Graffiti area that can be minimised to give you more visual real estate, a feature that's been found on Microsoft-based handhelds for years.

Palm devices use Graffiti 2.0's handwriting recognition system, where you write in block characters similar to traditional letters

The Palm OS has some distinct advantages over Windows Mobile 2003 when it comes to PC synchronisation. First, it's compatible with Apple and Windows-based computers. Palm also offers an email program called VersaMail, which works with a variety of similar applications such as Microsoft Outlook, Outlook Express, Microsoft Exchange and Lotus Notes. Check that VersaMail comes bundled with the handheld.

Third-party apps such as DataViz's Documents To Go allows you to work with Microsoft Office files on your PDA

The Palm platform also benefits from the enormous library of third-party applications. For example, if you intend to work with Microsoft Office files on your handheld, the Palm OS doesn't provide built-in support. However, many models come bundled with DataViz's Documents To Go Professional Edition, a tool that not only lets you work with said files, but does a better job synchronising with your PC and maintaining formatting than Windows Mobile Pocket Word and Pocket Excel. Check out CNET.co.uk's sister site Download.com for other apps, from games to expense-tracking tools to media players.

Back to top

Windows Mobile 2003

Pocket PC was renamed Windows Mobile 2003, well, a few years back. Microsoft touts the fact that Windows Mobile 2003 resembles desktop versions of Windows and is, therefore, easier to use. However, we feel the learning curve is actually steeper than that of Palm devices. But don't get discouraged -- anyone can quickly master the OS.

Where Palm offers just a single handwriting recognition system, Windows Mobile 2003 has three choices: Block Recognizer, which is similar to Grafitti; Letter Recognizer, which imitates the act of printing letters; and Transcriber, a system that recognises either printed or cursive handwriting, provided you write neatly. And as noted, Windows Mobile 2003 devices have a virtual input area that appears onscreen only when needed. When it's hidden, you have nearly 1/3 more screen real estate.

Windows Mobile 2003 is intended to mesh with all of Microsoft's software. It comes with a copy of Outlook and the synchronisation is top notch. All the fields from your Outlook contact list are sent to the handheld. However, if your business uses Lotus Notes or some other email system, you're in a bit of a pickle. And if you're on a Mac, you'll need to purchase third-party synchronisation software.

Windows Mobile devices come with mini versions of the Microsoft Office suite, such as Pocket Outlook

In addition to Pocket Outlook, you'll find Pocket versions of Word and Excel built into the OS. Unfortunately, your desktop files are converted to Windows Mobile-compatible files when travelling from PC to Pocket PC, a process that loses some formatting.

Whatever flaws the built-in applications may have, they can access a respectable library of third-party software available for Windows Mobile devices. Gamers and multimedia fans, in particular, will benefit from the collection of entertainment apps and media players that let you view native MPEG files and music-composition tools with built-in software synthesisers. Again, Download.com is a good resource for add-ons to your Pocket PC device.

Back to top