Four of the best Blu-ray players
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Ian Morris
Last updated: 18 Jan 2008
With HD DVD on its last legs, it seems like a pretty good time to do a round up of some of the best and most interesting Blu-ray players on the market. Of course, it's not all a bed of roses for Blu-ray. Despite having a lot of studio support, the players come in a variety of capabilities and not one of them supports the same specification.
For example, Sony's own BDP-S1E doesn't support Profile 1.1, which means that if you buy it, you won't be able to enjoy enhanced interactivity and picture-in-picture support. A sniff around and you might get it for less than £500, but that's still more expensive than Sony's own PlayStation 3.
The good news is that if you want a PS3, it's a good Blu-ray player. Some say it's the best -- and they might be right -- because it's upgradable, has all the features of Profile 2 and Profile 1.1, and can also play PS3 games. You can pick one up for about £300 these days, which means it's one of the better valued high-end players on the market. Of course, this is because the PS3 is being subsidised by Sony. So if 20 million people bought one and never bought any games, Sony would go bust in three minutes flat.
If you don't want a Sony player, then how about going for either the high end or the low end? At the bottom of the range, there is the Sharp BD-HP20H, which at just £300 really is quite cheap for a standalone. It doesn't support Profile 1.1, but then again neither does the Pioneer BDP-LX70 and it costs quite a lot more.

Compare Products
![]() Sony PlayStation 3 (40GB) |
![]() Sony BDP-S1E |
![]() Sharp BD-HP20H |
![]() Pioneer BDP-LX70 |
|
| Review date | 19 Oct 07 | 26 Oct 07 | 15 Jan 08 | 22 Oct 07 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £299.00 - £299.00 |
£650 | £286.49 - £319.97 |
£980 |
| Review summary | Sony's PlayStation 3 may be the most expensive next-gen console, and its launch titles aren't very impressive, but its swanky design and bevy of features, including a Blu-ray drive, make it hard to resist Read full review Full specification |
In many ways, the Sony BDP-S1E is a perfect snapshot of the current state of Blu-ray play. On the one hand, it shows to breathtaking effect just what awesome audio and especially video treats Blu-ray can deliver. But on the other hand, there are just too many reminders that Blu-ray is also essentially a work in progress Read full review Full specification |
Sharp is to be commended for being so competitive on price with its debut Blu-ray player, and for delivering some profoundly good HD picture quality. But its lack of some key features ultimately makes it feel too much like a first-generation trial run. Plus its HD upscaling of old DVDs also counts against it with people not yet ready to ditch their old DVD collection Read full review Full specification |
In a perfect world where we could judge the Pioneer BDP-LX70 purely on its performance standards, we'd be raving about it. But the HD disc situation right now is anything but perfect and once you put it in its proper market context, the LX70 becomes frustratingly difficult to recommend Read full review Full specification |
| User rating | ||||
| More Games Console reviews | More DVD or PVR reviews | More DVD or PVR reviews | More DVD or PVR reviews |





