Movies on the go: portable video players
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Guy Cocker
Last updated: 10 May 2005
Boring journeys should be a thing of the past, thanks to the wide range of portable video players on the market. While the ability to watch last night's episode of The Simpsons on the way to work may be enough to make some people part with £300, the technology is still evolving and putting video on the devices is sometimes difficult, so they're not still not for the complete novice.
By far the best effort comes from Archos, with the AV420. The ergonomics of the device are just right, the screen is of a good quality, and perhaps most importantly, you can transfer DivX files straight over without any pesky re-encoding.
Creative's Zen Portable Media Center is based on Microsoft's standard MC interface, which looks great and is easy to use. However, the unit could do with a diet -- it's far too bulky. It also can't record programmes from an external AV source. You'll also need a PC running Windows XP.
The Samsung YH-999 is a toe-dipping exercise for the Korean giant, and not an entirely successful one. If you've got a Media Center computer packed full of recordings then it's easy, but for 99 per cent of people it proves a little difficult to re-encode DivX files and other media. Still, it's well built and video looks good when played back.
Thomson's Lyra series had some success in the music arena before the iPod arrived, and now it's having a crack at the video market. The PDP2860 looks the part and offers a great picture quality. It's also easy to record from an AV source such as television, and the hard drive stores up to 40 hours. However, despite claiming to support DivX, the device had trouble coping with some test clips from the official Web site.
Compare Products
![]() Archos AV420 |
![]() Creative Zen Portable Media Center |
![]() Samsung YH-999 |
![]() Thomson Lyra PDP2860 |
|
| Review date | 14 May 05 | 14 May 05 | 11 May 05 | 14 May 05 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £320 | £300 | £350 | £300 |
| Review summary | It's not perfect, but the AV420 is by far the best portable video player we've seen Read full review |
Eight months after its announcement, the Creative Zen PMC is finally here. Despite its bulk, the player is solid, but it's the Microsoft Portable Media Center software that deserves most of the praise Read full review |
A few years ago the YH-999 might have seemed gimmicky, but now our lives are rich enough in multimedia content to justify a portable device to access this stuff on the move. Digital photos, video, MP3s and TV can all be transferred to the Samsung. It's not for shy types though -- the idea of a portable video player is still novel enough to guarantee an audience should you pull the YH-999 out in public Read full review |
Television recordings play back fine, but viewing purchased and downloaded video is harder Read full review |
| User rating | ||||
| Product type | Portable video player | Portable video player | Portable video player | Hard drive recorder |
| Playable media | MP3, WMA, JPEG, DivX | MP3, WMA, JPEG, DivX | MP3, WMA | MP3, WMA, JPEG, DivX |
| Hard drive size | 20 GB | 20 GB | 20 GB | 20 GB |
| Scart | 1 input, 1 output | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| Component | No | n/a | No | No |
| DVI | No | n/a | No | No |
| HDMI | No | n/a | No | No |
| Full specification | Full specification | Full specification | Full specification |
Want to compare other products?
You can choose up to four products to compare on the Compare Products page





