Best MP3 players for listening to podcasts
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Nate Lanxon
Last updated: 08 Nov 2007
Creative's Zen comes with software called ZenCast. ZenCast has an online podcast directory divided into different categories. You can browse new shows this way or simply paste a podcast feed URL into the software directly. If a video podcast isn't in a suitable format, ZenCast converts it. It's simple to use and makes the Zen an excellent podcasting choice.
Apple's iPod nano requires you use iTunes. Within the iTunes Store is a vast podcast library, freely browsable to anyone with an iTunes account. Once you've subscribed to a show, new episodes are automatically downloaded and -- if you allow it -- synced with your iPod. When you've listened to a podcast on the iPod, it shows up as having been listened to on your PC, too. Your playback position is also bookmarked so if you only listen to half a show, you can return hours, days, even weeks later and resume the show. The iPod offers the simplest podcast integration by far.
The new iRiver Clix -- often called the Clix 2 -- supports a third-party application from Podcast Ready. With a free account on the Podcast Ready Web site, you can browse shows or just paste a podcast feed URL into your account. A free download, MyPodder, sits in the Clix's memory and keeps track of what shows you've subscribed to whenever the player's connected. New shows are seamlessly transferred to the player. It's no iTunes, but it works and it's fairly easy.
Samsung's YP-P2 comes with the Samsung Media Studio, within which is a 'Datacast' function. Basically, this is Samsung's word for podcasts. Getting used to the Samsung software takes a little time. There's no podcast directory but if you've got the show's feed URL, it's easy to paste it into the 'subscribe' field. It's not a perfect solution and it's a bit tricky, but it does work.
Compare Products
![]() Creative Zen |
![]() Apple iPod nano (3rd gen, video) |
![]() iRiver Clix 2 |
![]() Samsung YP-P2 |
|
| Review date | 15 Oct 07 | 10 Sep 07 | 9 May 07 | 1 Nov 07 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £129 | £99 | £139 | £109 |
| Review summary | The Creative Zen looks great, sounds great and produces great video. It's a full-featured player with plenty of options for customisation. Although the SD card slot is a huge bonus, its contents are not included in the player's main menu, limiting its usefulness Read full review |
Apple's new iPod nano seems to be drawing equal amounts of ire and admiration. Although we miss the slender form of the second-generation iPod nano, we feel the latest edition has more going for it than against it. At less than £100, the 4GB iPod nano offers one of the richest user experiences we've seen on an MP3 player Read full review |
Quite simply the finest flash-based MP3 player you can buy at the moment - the second-generation Clix is feature-packed, easy to use, stunning aesthetics and it won't break the bank. There's almost nothing we would change or try to improve. If you're looking for an iPod nano killer, look no further Read full review |
The Samsung YP-P2 is a well-designed player and distinctly affordable for what it does. The only problem is that what it does just isn't as impressive as it could be. It sounds great and it's easy to use, but the lack of support for audio and video formats seriously hinders just how attractive an alternative this is to players from Cowon and Apple Read full review |
| User rating | ||||
| Product type | Flash | Flash | Flash | Flash |
| Weight | 65 g | 49 g | 55 g | 85 g |
| Supported digital audio standards | AAC, MP3, WMA, WAV | AAC, MP3, AIFF, WAV | OGG, MP3, WMA | MP3, WMA |
| Supported bit rates | 16-320 Kbps | n/a | 8-320 Kbps | n/a |
| Image display | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Tuner | FM | n/a | FM | FM |
| Input type | Microphone | n/a | Microphone | n/a |
| Supported interfaces | USB | USB | USB | USB |
| Full specification | Full specification | Full specification | Full specification |
Want to compare other products?
You can choose up to four products to compare on the Compare Products page






