iPod or iPhone?
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Nate Lanxon
Last updated: 03 Oct 2007
The iPod nano's tagline -- "A little video for everyone" -- is quite accurate. A little video is all you should put on here. If you want to carry complete seasons of TV shows, don't consider the nano. If you're mainly listening to MP3s, a couple of podcasts and some music videos, however, this might be the player for you. If you want to take complete show seasons with you, you'll need to look at...
... the iPod classic. It's the most capacious of all the new models, so it's perfect for carrying complete seasons of TV shows -- even complete catalogues of seasons. It's the one to consider if you like lossless-quality music, as these files take up vast amounts of space. If you don't think you need tens of gigabytes of storage but don't want a weedy little nano, you might want to make friends with...
... the iPod touch. With a massive screen, it's perfect for TV shows and photos. The typical touch owner is probably someone who wants to carry more video than music. Its huge screen is designed for images. If you spend time in coffee shops and airports, the Wi-Fi inside the touch will let you check email and buy songs from iTunes. If you like the touch but don't want to carry multiple devices around, it might be time to look at...
... the iPhone. It does practically everything the touch does, but it's also a phone and a camera. Plus, the entire Web is accessible wherever you have a mobile signal. The iPhone has 8GB of memory, so you can store roughly 1,000 songs, 12 TV episodes, 500 photos and 60 podcasts at once. If this suits you, and you need a phone and mobile Web browsing, you've found your perfect match.
Compare Products
![]() Apple iPod nano (3rd gen, video) |
![]() Apple iPod classic |
![]() Apple iPod touch |
![]() Apple iPhone |
|
| Review date | 10 Sep 07 | 18 Sep 07 | 19 Sep 07 | 30 Jun 07 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £99 | £229 | £269 | £269 |
| Review summary | Apple's new iPod nano seems to be drawing equal amounts of ire and admiration. Although we miss the slender form of the second-generation iPod nano, we feel the latest edition has more going for it than against it. At less than £100, the 4GB iPod nano offers one of the richest user experiences we've seen on an MP3 player Read full review Full specification |
Apple has not only exceeded our expectations, it's exceeded ones we didn't even have. The iPod classic is a superb audio player with a huge wealth of well-integrated features and intuitive navigation. Our only real concern is that menus can be laggy. Apart from that, outstanding Read full review Full specification |
For better or worse, the iPod touch is clearly the iPhone's baby brother. Like most products that roll out of Apple, the touch shows the love of committed designers, hardware engineers and usability experts. While it may not be the slam dunk we were hoping for, it is an unquestionably cool product that continues Apple's legacy of sleek, innovative design Read full review Full specification |
Despite some important missing features, a slow data network and call quality that doesn't always deliver, the Apple iPhone sets a new benchmark for an integrated mobile phone and MP3 player Read full review Full specification |
| User rating | ||||
| More MP3 Player reviews | More MP3 Player reviews | More MP3 Player reviews | More Mobile Phone reviews |







