Typical price: £305
What is it: An MP3, WMA and WAV player from Toshiba
What we think: Toshiba adds some useful technology and features not found on the iPod, but too many unnecessary limitations, sloppy software, and counterintuitive ergonomics add up to a wasted opportunity
Toshiba Gigabeat MEG-F60S (60GB, Silver) Review
Reviewed on: 29 July 2005
Your first instinct when using the cross-shaped control array is to slide your fingers up and down the bars. Bad instinct. Each tip of the cross, as well as the intersection, is actually a button. You can display a function map on the screen for a reminder of which tip accomplishes which action. Unfortunately, the intersection of the bars is not the Select button -- pressing the right tip activates or confirms a selected feature. The intersection is also the play/pause control, but the area for this important function is so limited that we often needed multiple taps before enough pressure was applied to toggle between the two.

Like the iPod's, the Gigabeat's large and bright 56mm colour screen adds a high level of readability to the track information, even when the backlight is off. You can choose between eight different wallpaper designs -- uselessly labelled Setup1 through to Setup5 for the presets and User1 through to User3 for the user-defined designs. The 10 screen themes define how information is displayed on the screen: for instance, with large or small text and with portrait or left- or right-handed landscape orientation. The play mode, the battery meter, and the time are also displayed.

The Gigabeat's cradle is both a boon and a bane. On its front are buttons for direct syncing and CD ripping. But the cradle includes USB 1.1 and USB 2.0 connectors as well as an AC input. Not all PCs or laptops can power an accessory through a USB connection, however. Our Gateway M210 laptop doesn't, so the cradle had to be connected to a power source in order for it to work. When using Windows Media 10.0, you also need to use the cradle's USB 1.1 connection rather than a direct Gigabeat-to-PC USB 2.0 connection.

Included with the Gigabeat is Toshiba's Gigabeat Room (or Gigaroom, for short) music-management software, with an icon-heavy interface that takes some getting used to. Unfortunately, the lightweight Gigaroom handles only ripped CDs. You have to use other software to transfer licensed tracks.
Tell us what you think
Do you own this product? Want to share your experiences with other CNET UK users?
Write your own review of the Toshiba Gigabeat MEG-F60S (60GB, Silver)
Can't find the product you're looking for? Want to suggest a product for review?

Special Offers from our Sponsors
Latest MP3 player Reviews
Philips GoGear Opus
Good little player, but it's outclassed by competitors like the iPod nano and Sony NWZ-S639F
Sony Walkman NWZ-X1050 (X series)
Offers excellent sound quality, but its high price means the iPod touch won't have too many sleepless nights
Samsung YP-U5
Good sound quality, an appealing design and decent battery life make it a great secondary MP3 player
on MP3 & Digital Music
Dell reportedly developing Android-based rival to iPod touch
The company is working on a pocket-sized Internet device to take on Apple's media player, according to a report in The Wall Street Journal
More:
Special Feature
Listen to the CNET UK Podcast
Subscribe to our weekly show where the team chat about the latest, hottest gadgets and Web weirdness





