Windows Media Center (Viiv) PCs
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Rory Reid
Last updated: 28 Jul 2006
The Windows Media Center Edition (MCE) operating system is a great OS. It provides all the functions of Windows XP Professional Edition, and gives you a dedicated multimedia interface that provides instant and easy access to audio, video, images and in many cases television.
Getting the most from an MCE PC depends very much on what hardware it's paired with, and there are some key points to consider before you make a buying decision. Possibly the most important factor is the physical design of the computer. If you're using it in your living room, you'll want to ensure that it blends in as seamlessly as possible with your existing audio visual setup -- large desktop PCs will look completely out of place.
Just as importantly, MCE PCs should have low operational noise. There's nothing worse than having a computer making a huge racket next to your television when you're trying to enjoy something as simple as DVD playback. Look for computers that make less than 30dB of noise during operating, as anything above this will be annoying.
More advanced users will want to ensure their MCE PC comes with at least one TV tuner. Many of the latest Media Center PCs now ship with hybrid tuners that let you watch either analogue or digital (Freeview) television programmes. More advanced models ship with dual hybrid tuners, so you can record two programmes while you watch another (and even a fourth in a picture-in-picture box).
Multimedia file hoarders will need to consider factors such as the size of the hard disk. On average, you'll need around 1GB of disk space for each hour of high-quality video recorded by MCE, so unless you intend to continually delete or back up movies you've already recorded, you should get as large a hard disk as possible.
Finally, ensure your MCE PC comes with all the appropriate connectors to link it to the rest of your AV equipment. If you have an existing amplifier and speaker setup, look at the types of audio and video inputs/outputs available, or you'll have trouble integrating it with your existing hardware.
Compare Products
![]() Acer Aspire iDea 500 |
![]() Sony Vaio VGC-RC204 |
![]() Shuttle XPC M1000 |
![]() Dell Dimension 5150c |
|
| Review date | 13 Jul 06 | 15 Jun 06 | 20 Feb 06 | 27 Jan 06 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £900 | £1,799 | £1,300 | £1,349 |
| Review summary | The Acer Aspire iDea 500 is the best Media Center PC we've seen. Aesthetically it's inspired by traditional AV equipment, so it'll sit alongside or replace your existing DVD player without looking out of place. It's not very upgradeable, but it's packed with just the right multimedia components to make the most of the Intel Viiv platform Read full review |
A good example of how Blu-ray discs and drives can benefit a PC. It's well-designed, powerful and good value for money. It's only let down slightly by its lack of HDCP compatibility, so it can't play forthcoming content-protected Blu-ray movies in full high definition Read full review |
The M1000 is an almost flawless interpretation of the Media Center concept. It looks excellent, runs quietly, has good all-round performance, and has the type of I/O connectivity you'd expect from a premium AV product. If you're after a Media Center PC that cuts no corners, look no further Read full review |
The Dimension 5150c is one of the first PCs to use the Intel Viiv specification, and it makes a good first impression. Its BTX chassis almost achieves the Holy Grail of silent operation. Useless at running games, its Pentium D processor gives it strong performance elsewhere, and it is surprisingly inexpensive. Some users will be disappointed at the lack of a TV tuner, but if recording television isn't a priority then the 5150c is a winner in almost every respect Read full review |
| User rating | ||||
| Clock speed | 2.16 GHz | 3.2 GHz | 1.73 GHz | 2.8 GHz |
| Processor type | Core Duo T2600 | Pentium D 940 | Pentium M | Pentium D 820 |
| Processor family | Intel Core | Intel Pentium | Intel Pentium | Intel Pentium |
| Processor manufacturer | Intel | Intel | Intel | Intel |
| RAM installed | 1024 MB | 1024 MB | 512 MB | 1024 MB |
| Hard drive size | 250 GB | 300 GB | 300 GB | 250 GB |
| Graphics processor | Intel integrated | Nvidia GeForce 7600 GT | Nvidia GeForce 6600 LE | ATI X600 SE |
| Display type | None | None | n/a | LCD |
| Operating system | Microsoft Windows XP Media Center Edition | Microsoft Windows XP Media Center Edition | Microsoft Windows XP Media Center Edition | Microsoft Windows XP Media Center Edition |
| CD / DVD type | n/a | 1x Blu-ray | n/a | DVD±RW |
| Max supported RAM | n/a | n/a | 2 GB | 4096 GB |
| Full specification | Full specification | Full specification | Full specification |
Want to compare other products?
You can choose up to four products to compare on the Compare Products page





