Affordable 3CCD camcorders
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Chris Stevens
Last updated: 26 May 2006
One person's idea of affordable may be another's vision of bankruptcy, but in the world of 3CCD camcorders, only the bold and the wealthy survive. These may look like fairly expensive consumer items, but anyone familiar with 3CCD models will know that all the camcorders on offer here are actually pretty good value, and in the case of two (the Sony and the Canon), have even been used to record feature films that have enjoyed a cinema release. Success on the silver screen doesn't come guaranteed with these models, but at the low end of the 3CCD market, there's still plenty of thrills to be had.
For those who didn't pay attention in science lessons, a 3CCD camcorder uses three separate CCDs (charge coupled devices) to independently capture red, green and blue light entering the lens. This gives you a clear and vivid picture that trounces the more common single-CCD models that currently own the scene. If you buy one of these, you really are bribing your way into the next level of home movie making.
The Sony and Canon models are both semi-pro cameras that perform excellently in almost all lighting conditions. The Sony has the edge for resolution, it's an HD camcorder, while the XL2 has the advantage of an interchangeable lens (though it is possible to hack the FX1 by forcefully detaching the current lens mounting and custom building a 35mm film camera lens. Wave goodbye to your warranty though).
The Panasonic and JVC models have a significantly lower price tag. You'll still get great results from these, but your hopes of Hollywood success may be slightly reduced.
Compare Products
![]() Panasonic NV-GS300 |
![]() JVC Everio GZ-MC500 |
![]() Sony HDR-FX1 |
![]() Canon XL2 |
|
| Review date | 2 May 06 | 22 Jul 05 | 2 May 05 | 18 Apr 05 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £530 | £800 | £2,200 | £3,940.60 - £4,691.99 |
| Review summary | Offering superb video quality under a wide variety of lighting conditions, the Panasonic NV-GS300 is an excellent choice if you typically shoot in automatic mode. Prosumers may find the limited choice and the awkward accessibility of the manual settings frustrating, however Read full review |
Not only does it look like a professional camcorder, but the MC500's performance matches its appearance. Instead of the more common single CCD, the MC500 uses three separate CCDs to capture a far better clarity of colour. The biggest benefit of the MC500, however, is the size of the thing -- it's tiny Read full review |
For the price, the best HD camera currently available Read full review |
Canon returns to the state of the art in DV but doesn't set a new standard Read full review |
| User rating | ||||
| Recording media | MiniDV | Hard drive | MiniDV | MiniDV |
| Number of CCDs | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 |
| Size (W x H x D) | 76x73x135 mm | 80x55x118 mm | 150x180x366 mm | 226x221x495 mm |
| Sensor type | CCD | CCD | CCD | CCD |
| Optical zoom | 10 x | 10 x | 12 x | 20 x |
| Digital zoom | 700 x | 40 x | n/a | n/a |
| Image stabiliser | Optical | Electronic | Optical (Super Steady Shot) | n/a |
| Display size | 69 mm | 46 mm | 89 mm | 51 mm |
| Display resolution | 123000 pixels | n/a | 250880 pixels | 200000 pixels |
| Effective sensor resolution | n/a | 2073600 pixels | 1070000 pixels | n/a |
| Full specification | Full specification | Full specification | Full specification |
Want to compare other products?
You can choose up to four products to compare on the Compare Products page






