Best camcorders for a summer holiday
Round-up reviews let you compare four related products and find out which one is best for you
Round-up by: Chris Stevens
Last updated: 12 May 2005
So you're jetting off to some exotic location. You've got two choices about what kind of video camera you take: either something light and nimble that will tuck into the back of your rucksack, or a professional 3CCD monster that will do justice to the African savanna.
Only one camcorder in our line-up will really make wildlife footage shine, and that's the Sony FX1. But it's also the bulkiest. If you need great looking video from a compact camcorder, a hard disk model like the JVC Everio is a good trade-off.
Other important considerations when choosing a holiday camcorder include battery life and recordable media. While hard-drive based camcorders are almost unbelievably tiny, they also use the most expensive media. Alternatively, DVD camcorders offer a cheap and easy way of archiving video, but you'll have to sacrifice image quality.
In our experience, MiniDV camcorders are still the best format to take on holiday. You won't have problems buying a replacement MiniDV tape in the Congo. You might, on the other hand, struggle to find an extra Microdrive for your JVC Everio.
Compare Products
![]() Hitachi DZ-MV580E |
![]() Sony HDR-FX1 |
![]() JVC Everio GZ-MC200 |
![]() Canon MV750i |
|
| Review date | 14 May 05 | 2 May 05 | 17 May 05 | 7 Oct 04 |
| Editors' rating |
|
|
|
|
| Price range | £450 | £1,754.95 - £1,754.95 |
£600 | £360 |
| Review summary | The Hitachi does its job extremely well, and you may love the simplicity of recording straight on to a DVD that you can play in your home DVD player. However, compared to a MiniDV camera in the same price range, the Hitachi is less flexible and captures a slightly lower quality image. For those without directorial aspirations the Hitachi is a total solution, but for budding filmmakers the limited options for transferring your footage to PC are just too restricting Read full review |
For the price, the best HD camera currently available Read full review |
It's largely thanks to the massive success of the iPod that microdrives have become so affordable. It was about time some great DV camcorders turned up with hard disks tucked away in their bellies, so we were pleased to find the JVC MC-200 is such a small and elegant use of this technology. Although you'll need to buy additional microdrives to store more than 60 minutes of footage on location, hard disk really is the future of DV Read full review |
This affordable MiniDV camera offers a good range of home-video-oriented features, as well as comfortable, smooth operation, but its video quality doesn't rise above average Read full review |
| User rating | ||||
| Recording media | DVD | MiniDV | Hard drive | MiniDV |
| Number of CCDs | 1 | 3 | 1 | 1 |
| Size (W x H x D) | 64x89x146 mm | 150x180x366 mm | 41x104x71 mm | 53x95x139 mm |
| Sensor type | CCD | CCD | CCD | CCD |
| Effective sensor resolution | 120000 pixels | 1070000 pixels | 2120000 pixels | 340000 pixels |
| Optical zoom | 10 x | 12 x | 10 x | 22 x |
| Digital zoom | 240 x | n/a | 200 x | 440 x |
| Image stabiliser | Electronic | Optical (Super Steady Shot) | Electronic | Electronic |
| Display size | 64 mm | 89 mm | 46 mm | 64 mm |
| Display resolution | n/a | 250880 pixels | 130000 pixels | 112000 pixels |
| Full specification | Full specification | Full specification | Full specification |
Want to compare other products?
You can choose up to four products to compare on the Compare Products page





